Home FAQ

Does it matter what brand of air filter you get?

The short answer is yes, the brand of air filter you choose can make a difference in the performance and effectiveness of your HVAC system. While all air filters serve the same basic function of trapping airborne particles, the quality, construction, and filtration capabilities can vary significantly between brands and models.

Understanding Air Filter Brands and Performance

Air filters come in a wide range of materials, designs, and MERV (Minimum Efficiency Reporting Value) ratings, which indicate their ability to capture different sized particles. Higher MERV ratings generally mean more effective filtration, but also increased airflow resistance. The brand you choose can impact factors like:

Filtration Efficiency: Some brands use higher-quality filter media that can capture smaller particles like dust, pollen, and pet dander more effectively.

Airflow Restriction: Poorly designed filters can restrict airflow through your HVAC system, reducing efficiency and putting more strain on the equipment.

Durability: Cheaper filters may deteriorate more quickly, requiring more frequent replacement and potentially allowing more contaminants to pass through.

Fit and Seal: Filters that don't fit properly in the filter housing can allow unfiltered air to bypass the filter media.

Choosing a high-quality, well-reviewed air filter brand can help ensure optimal HVAC performance, improved indoor air quality, and longer equipment lifespan.

Factors to Consider When Selecting an Air Filter

When choosing an air filter, it's important to consider the specific needs of your HVAC system and home. Key factors to weigh include:

MERV Rating: Higher MERV ratings (13-16) provide the most effective filtration but may require more frequent replacement and cause greater airflow restriction.

Filter Size: Ensure the filter fits the designated slot in your HVAC system for a proper seal.

Filter Type: Options include pleated, flat, and electrostatic filters, each with their own advantages.

Replacement Frequency: More expensive filters may last longer between changes, but cheaper filters may need to be replaced more often.

By carefully considering these factors and selecting a high-quality air filter brand, you can help maintain optimal HVAC performance and indoor air quality in your home.

What brand of air filter is best?

The "best" air filter brand depends on your needs, but Filtrete is often a top choice for residential HVAC systems due to its strong performance in tests, especially for allergy sufferers, while brands like ACDelco and Purolator/Wix excel in engine air filtration. For air purifiers, Winix and Coway are highly rated, particularly for their high efficiency and features, and Levoit is a great budget-friendly option.
This video compares different furnace filter brands: 59sProject FarmYouTube · Feb 14, 2021
For residential HVAC systems (furnace/AC)

Filtrete (3M): A popular and highly-rated brand for home use, particularly the Filtrete Micro Allergen Defense for allergy-prone households. Some tests have shown it performs very well for capturing particles.
Honeywell: Another strong contender, with some models performing very well in tests, especially for capturing both large and small particles, according to this YouTube video.
FilterBuy: A good option if you're looking for value, with some MERV 8 filters praised for being effective for general use, notes this review guide.
Rheem: A solid budget-friendly choice for low-traffic homes.

For car engines

ACDelco: Performed best in one test for engine air filters, allowing the least amount of dirt through, says StrikeEngine.
Baldwin: A strong second-place performer in the same test, notes StrikeEngine.
Purolator and Wix: These brands were highlighted as outperforming others in protecting engines over the long term, according to this YouTube video.

This video compares different car air filter brands: 1mProject FarmYouTube · Mar 9, 2020
For air purifiers (room-sized)

Winix: Often ranked as one of the best, with high CADR (Clean Air Delivery Rate) and features like app control, say Air Purifier First and RTINGS.com.
Coway: Considered a top brand, especially for allergies, and consistently ranked high for performance, according to Air Purifier First and RTINGS.com.
Levoit: A standout choice for the best balance of performance and price, with smart features and a great app, according to HouseFresh.
Alen: Another top contender, specifically noted for being ultra-quiet, says Air Purifier First.

Do more expensive air filters really make a difference?

More expensive air filters can work better at filtering the air, but it depends on the type and if it's appropriate for your HVAC system. High-efficiency filters can capture smaller particles like allergens, which improves indoor air quality, but they can also restrict airflow, forcing your system to work harder and potentially reducing its efficiency or causing damage. Therefore, it's important to choose a filter with the right MERV rating for your specific system, as the most expensive option isn't always the best.
This video demonstrates the difference between a cheap and an expensive air filter: 1mHome, Life & Leisure DIYYouTube · Feb 19, 2025
When expensive filters are better

For improved air quality: Higher-cost filters with higher MERV ratings are more effective at trapping smaller particles like pet dander, pollen, and mold spores.
For specific needs: Some premium filters include activated carbon, which can help reduce odors in your home.
For certain systems: In systems that can accommodate them, such as those with a 4-inch or thicker filter slot, higher MERV filters can be a good choice without causing significant airflow issues.
For less frequent changes: Some high-quality filters can last longer, potentially up to a year, meaning you replace them less often.

This video demonstrates the filtration process with a cross-section of both cheap and expensive air filters: 56sFilterbuyYouTube · Jul 2, 2024
When cheaper filters are better

To avoid system strain: A cheap, low-MERV filter will have less resistance, preventing your HVAC system from working too hard.
For standard filtration: If you don't have specific issues like allergies or odors, a basic, low-MERV filter is sufficient for protecting your equipment from large dust particles.

What to consider when choosing

System design: Your HVAC system's ducts were designed for a specific airflow. A filter that is too restrictive can cause problems like frozen coils or reduced efficiency.
MERV rating: This rating indicates a filter's efficiency. While a high MERV is good for air quality, anything too high for your system can cause issues. A MERV 8 or below is often sufficient for most residential systems.
Filter thickness: A 1-inch filter is more likely to become restrictive with a high MERV rating than a thicker 4-inch filter.
Other additives: If you are considering filters with additives like activated carbon, it's best to do so for a specific reason, like odor control, rather than just because they are expensive.

You can watch this video to learn about the potential for air filter damage to your AC system: 59sAtlas ACYouTube · Mar 19, 2025

Is MERV 8 or 11 better for homes?

For most homes, MERV 8 is a good, cost-effective choice for basic air filtration. However, if anyone in your household has allergies, asthma, or you have pets, MERV 11 provides superior filtration for smaller particles like pet dander and smoke, as long as your HVAC system can handle the increased airflow resistance.
This video explains the differences between MERV 8 and MERV 11 air filters and which one might be right for you: 49sThe DIY HVAC GuyYouTube · Mar 8, 2023
MERV 8

Good for: Basic filtration, capturing larger particles like dust and lint.
Ideal if: You have a newer home, no pets, and no significant allergies or respiratory issues.
Benefit: More affordable and creates less strain on your HVAC system.

MERV 11

Good for: Better air quality, capturing smaller particles like pet dander, smoke, and smog.
Ideal if: Anyone in the home has allergies, asthma, or other respiratory concerns.
Benefit: Captures a wider range of airborne contaminants for cleaner air.

Important considerations for both

HVAC system capacity: A higher MERV rating creates more airflow resistance, which can strain your HVAC system and increase energy consumption. Make sure your system can handle a MERV 11 filter, or consult your system's manual or an HVAC professional.
Regular replacement: No matter which filter you choose, replacing it regularly is crucial for maintaining good indoor air quality and preventing damage to your HVAC system.

Does air filter brand make a difference?

The brand of your air filter does matter.
These materials can include finer filter media that are more effective at capturing a wide range of airborne particles, including dust, pollen, pet dander, and allergens. Filtration Efficiency: Different brands offer filters with varying levels of filtration efficiency.

Kevin Bennett

Company Owner

Kevin Bennet is the founder and owner of Kevin's Autos, a leading automotive service provider in Australia. With a deep commitment to customer satisfaction and years of industry expertise, Kevin uses his blog to answer the most common questions posed by his customers. From maintenance tips to troubleshooting advice, Kevin's articles are designed to empower drivers with the knowledge they need to keep their vehicles running smoothly and safely.