Home FAQ

How do I know if my tensioner or pulley is bad?

Common signs point to a failing belt tensioner or pulley include unusual belt noises, belt slipping or looseness, visible wear on the belt or pulleys, and bearing noises from the tensioner. If you notice these issues, inspect and plan for replacement to avoid a roadside breakdown.

Common symptoms to watch for

Identifying a failing tensioner or pulley starts with listening for noises, watching belt condition, and noting how the belt behaves during engine operation. The list below highlights the most reliable warning signs.

Squealing, chirping, or grinding noises from the belt area, especially at start-up or under load

Belt slipping, jumping, or appearing noticeably loose during acceleration

Cracks, glazing, fraying, or missing ribs on the belt

Visible wobble or excessive play in the tensioner pulley when the engine is off and the belt is removed

Bearings inside a tensioner or pulley that produce grinding, squeaking, or rough feel when you rotate the pulley by hand with the belt removed

Misaligned pulleys or the belt riding on the edge of a pulley, causing unusual wear

An automatic tensioner that cannot maintain consistent belt tension, leading to slipping or squealing

If you observe multiple signs, the problem is likely with the tensioner or a pulley rather than a different belt component. Seek a professional diagnosis if the symptoms persist or worsen, especially while driving.

Safe at-home checks you can perform

Before heading to a shop, you can conduct non-invasive checks to gauge whether the tensioner or pulley is at fault. These steps should be done with the engine fully off and cooled, and you should avoid any actions that involve moving parts while the engine is running.

Visually inspect the belt for cracks, glazing, fraying, or missing chunks that would justify replacement

With the belt removed, rotate each pulley by hand. A smooth, quiet rotation indicates a healthy bearing; roughness, grinding, or noticeable play suggests wear

Check pulley alignment by looking along the belt path. If pulleys do not sit in a single plane or the belt tracks off-center, there may be misalignment or a worn pulley

Look for signs of leaks or fluid around hydraulic tensioners. Oil or coolant near the tensioner can compromise bearing life

If your manual or service guide provides a belt deflection spec, test tension by pressing the belt midway between pulleys and comparing with the recommended deflection

Note: Do not attempt to disassemble or force components while the engine is operating. If you are unsure or uncomfortable performing these checks, seek a qualified mechanic for an inspection to avoid injury or further damage.

What to do next: professional diagnosis and replacement

Professional diagnosis is advised when you detect symptoms or after at-home checks reveal bearing wear, misalignment, or excessive belt deflection. A mechanic will typically:

Inspect all related pulleys for wear, cracks, or damage

Test belt tension precisely using manufacturer specifications or a belt tension gauge

Check the tensioner’s spring or hydraulic mechanism for proper force and response

Replace worn tensioner and/or pulleys, and replace the belt with the correct type and length for your vehicle

Replacement decisions depend on the age of the belt and the tensioner, the vehicle’s service schedule, and the observed condition during inspection. A failed tensioner can risk belt failure, which might lead to loss of power steering, alternator, or cooling fan operation, and in worst-case scenarios, engine overheating.

When to replace and what to expect

Immediate danger signs

If the belt shows severe cracking, if the tensioner leaks fluid, or if the belt suddenly loosens and causes loss of essential systems while driving, pull over safely and arrange for roadside assistance. Do not drive a vehicle with a suspected belt failure.

What to expect in a typical repair

A standard repair will involve replacing the belt, the tensioner, and possibly one or more pulleys. Mechanics will torque bolts to factory specifications and re-check belt tension after installation. Plan for a multi-point inspection to prevent a repeat failure, as worn components often travel in packs under the hood.

Summary

Key signals of a bad tensioner or pulley include unusual belt noises, belt slip or looseness, visible wear on the belt or pulleys, and rough or wobbly bearings. Start with a careful visual inspection and non-invasive hand tests when the engine is off, then consult a professional if you detect wear, misalignment, or questionable tension. Regular maintenance per your vehicle’s manual can prevent unexpected belt failures and keep accessories running smoothly.

What is the difference between idler pulley and tensioner pulley?

An idler pulley is a fixed pulley that guides a belt's path, while a tensioner pulley uses a spring-loaded arm to apply constant pressure to the belt to maintain tension. The idler pulley's main job is to redirect the belt, ensuring it wraps around accessory pulleys properly. The tensioner's main job is to automatically keep the belt tight, preventing it from slipping and ensuring efficient power transfer.

Feature	Idler Pulley	Tensioner Pulley
Primary Function	Guides the belt's path and direction	Maintains proper belt tension
Movement	Mounts in a fixed position and does not move during operation	Has a spring-loaded arm that pivots to absorb vibrations and maintain tension
Role	Ensures the belt wraps correctly around other components	Prevents the belt from slipping or becoming too loose
How it works	A simple, freely spinning pulley	A spring-loaded mechanism applies a constant force

How to diagnose a bad tensioner pulley?

You can diagnose a bad tensioner pulley by listening for noises like chirping or grinding, and by visually inspecting the pulley for physical damage like cracks or excessive wear. Another key test is to manually spin the pulley after removing the belt—it should not feel rough or spin too freely, and there should be no side-to-side play.
Auditory and visual checks

Listen for noises: Squealing or chirping noises, especially on startup, can indicate belt slippage due to a failing tensioner. Grinding or humming sounds often point to a worn-out bearing.
Smell for burning: A burning rubber smell suggests the belt is overheating and slipping from lack of proper tension.
Look for physical damage: Inspect the pulley for cracks, chips, or dents. Also, check for discoloration or signs of excessive wear, such as rubber build-up on the pulley's surface.
Check belt condition: A bad tensioner can cause premature belt wear, so look for signs like fraying, cracking, or excessive shininess on the belt.

Manual inspection (with engine off)

Remove the drive belt: Follow your vehicle's service manual to safely remove the serpentine belt.
Check for play: Grab the pulley and try to rock it back and forth. There should be no side-to-side or up-and-down play.
Spin the pulley: Rotate the pulley with your fingers. It should spin smoothly.
- Bad sign: If it feels rough, gritty, or difficult to turn, the bearing is failing.
- Bad sign: If it spins more than one or two revolutions, it has likely lost its grease and is a failure waiting to happen.
Check for proper tension: Test the tensioner arm to ensure it is not weak.
- Bad sign: If it moves too easily or doesn't apply firm pressure, the spring may be weak.
- Bad sign: For hydraulic tensioners, check for any signs of fluid leaks.
Inspect the mounting bolts: Ensure the tensioner's mounting bolts are tight, as loose bolts can cause similar symptoms.

What to do if the tensioner is bad

Replace the pulley: Replace the tensioner pulley with a new one, and inspect the drive belt for wear. It's a good practice to replace the belt at the same time.
Consider other components: If the tensioner is a hydraulic type, check the fluid reservoir for leaks and consider a full replacement if necessary.
Consult a professional: If you are unsure about any of these steps, it's best to have a qualified mechanic diagnose and fix the problem to avoid further damage.

What does it sound like when your serpentine belt is going bad?

A failing serpentine belt typically sounds like a high-pitched squealing or chirping, especially when the engine starts, accelerates, or when accessories like the air conditioning are turned on. If the noise gets worse over time, it could indicate a worn-out belt or misaligned pulleys and is a sign the belt needs immediate attention.
This video explains what a bad serpentine belt sounds like and why it happens: 53sHonest Mechanic ColoradoYouTube · Jan 2, 2024
Common sounds and their causes

Squealing or chirping: This is the most common sound and is often caused by the belt slipping on the pulleys. This happens because the belt is worn, stretched, or improperly tensioned.
Consistent high-pitched squeal: A constant squeal that keeps pace with the engine's revolutions per minute (RPM) is also a sign of a failing belt.
Tapping or slapping noise: In more extreme cases, a harsh tapping or slapping sound that varies with RPMs can be a sign of a belt that is torn or missing chunks.

What to do when you hear these sounds

Do not ignore it: These sounds are a warning that the belt is failing and could snap, causing a sudden loss of power to critical components like the alternator and power steering pump.
Check for other symptoms: A bad belt can also cause other issues, such as your A/C not working, your steering becoming harder to turn, or dashboard warning lights, including the battery or check engine light.
Take it to a mechanic: It's best to have a mechanic inspect the belt as soon as you hear these noises to prevent potential further damage.

How do I know if my engine pulley is bad?

You can tell if an engine pulley is bad by listening for squealing, grinding, or rattling noises, looking for excessive vibration or wobbling, and checking the drive belt for signs of uneven wear or misalignment. A more definitive test is to remove the drive belt and spin each pulley by hand to feel for a gritty sensation or excessive play.
Signs of a bad pulley
Auditory signs

Squealing or chirping: This can be caused by a belt slipping on a worn or seized pulley.
Grinding or rattling: A failing bearing in the pulley can make a gritty, grinding, or rattling sound.
Knocking or slapping: A bad pulley may lead to a loose belt that slaps against other components.

Visual and tactile signs

Excessive vibration: A bad pulley can cause the engine or steering wheel to vibrate.
Wobbling: Check for any side-to-side wobble while the engine is running or with the belt removed.
Belt damage: Look for signs of uneven wear, cracking, or misalignment on the drive belt, which can indicate a bad pulley is misaligning it.
Corrosion or rust: Orange dust or rust around the pulley can signal a problem.
Rubber marks: Rubber from the belt may be seen on the pulley if the belt is rubbing against a seized or misaligned pulley.
Cracks or chips: Inspect for any physical damage, especially on plastic pulleys.

Functional signs

Accessory failure: Accessories like the alternator, water pump, or power steering pump may stop working if their drive belt comes off due to a pulley issue.
Overheating: A malfunctioning water pump pulley can cause the engine to overheat.
Check Engine Light: In some cases, a bad crankshaft pulley can cause the check engine light to come on.

How to perform a pulley check

Visually inspect: With the engine off, look for the signs listed above, such as corrosion, cracks, or belt wear.
Spin the pulley: If possible and safe to do so, remove the drive belt and spin each pulley by hand. A good pulley will spin smoothly and freely.
- Feel for grittiness: A bad bearing will feel gritty or rough.
- Listen for noise: A bad bearing may make a noise as you spin it.
- Check for play: A good pulley should have no noticeable side-to-side movement. If it wobbles or has "play," the bearing is likely bad.

2:45BAD SERPENTINE BELT, BAD PULLEY OR BAD TENSIONER??YouTubeTop 5 Auto Repairs · 2y 0:11if this the belt making noise or one of the pulleys? and if it is one of the ...RedditCycles_wp · 3y 0:20Not sure if you guys can tell. But is it a bad bearing? Bad pulley? Recently ...RedditDistrictLeaker · 3y 1:00Diagnosing a failing belt tensioner pulleyYouTube3V Johnny · 2y 0:06Pulley Seized?? : r/mechanicRedditStraightRamenJZ · 2y 0:12Could this be a bad or loose belt or a bad pulley : r/GMT400Reddit32_chambers · 1y 0:45Idler pulley making a noise I think and the alternator is chirping? : r ...RedditNo_Government01 · 2y 0:57Engine Idler pulley WHINE STOPSYouTubeEasy Fix · 2y 0:28Pulley bearing bad? : r/mechanicRedditDeleted User · 1y (function(){
(this||self).Bqpk9e=function(f,d,n,e,k,p){var g=document.getElementById(f);if(g&&(g.offsetWidth!==0||g.offsetHeight!==0)){var l=g.querySelector("div"),h=l.querySelector("div"),a=0;f=Math.max(l.scrollWidth-l.offsetWidth,0);if(d>0&&(h=h.children,a=h[d].offsetLeft-h[0].offsetLeft,e)){for(var m=a=0;m

Kevin Bennett

Company Owner

Kevin Bennet is the founder and owner of Kevin's Autos, a leading automotive service provider in Australia. With a deep commitment to customer satisfaction and years of industry expertise, Kevin uses his blog to answer the most common questions posed by his customers. From maintenance tips to troubleshooting advice, Kevin's articles are designed to empower drivers with the knowledge they need to keep their vehicles running smoothly and safely.