How reliable is the 2019 Toyota Highlander?

The 2019 Toyota Highlander is generally considered a reliable choice within the midsize SUV segment, benefiting from Toyota’s reputation for durability, strong resale value, and manageable maintenance costs. In short, it tends to perform well in reliability surveys and everyday ownership.

In this article, we take a closer look at independent reliability ratings, real-world owner experiences, and practical guidance for buying a used 2019 Highlander. The goal is to help readers gauge how this model holds up over time and what to watch for when evaluating a used example.

Independent reliability ratings and what they mean

Reliability surveys and industry metrics offer a high-level view of how the Highlander tends to perform over time, but they are best interpreted alongside owner experience and service history.

Sources and scoring notes

Consumer Reports and J.D. Power have historically placed Toyota SUVs, including the Highlander, among the more dependable options in the segment. While individual model years may vary, the 2019 Highlander generally benefits from Toyota’s long-standing emphasis on durable powertrains and solid build quality.

• Consumer Reports reliability: The Highlander typically earns above-average reliability scores for its class, reflecting fewer reported problems relative to peers over the long term.


• J.D. Power: The brand’s overall reliability and quality scores for Toyotas in the SUV category are usually strong, with the Highlander frequently ranking well among three-row crossover utility vehicles.


• Recall and service history: Toyota runs a broad recall program; for a used 2019 Highlander, it’s wise to verify that all open recalls have been addressed and that routine maintenance has been kept up.

Taken together, these signals point to a favorable reliability outlook for a well-maintained 2019 Highlander, with caveats tied to individual vehicle history and mileage.

Real-world ownership and maintenance costs

Beyond survey scores, actual ownership data point to predictable maintenance needs and reasonable running costs for a three-row SUV of this age. The choice between gasoline and hybrid powertrains also shapes long-term efficiency and upkeep.

• Gasoline V6 models offer solid performance and generally reasonable maintenance costs for a mainstream SUV, with typical service items following standard Toyota intervals.


• Highlander Hybrid models deliver notably better fuel efficiency, which can translate into lower fuel expenses over time, especially for higher-mileage drivers or those with long daily commutes.


• Common ongoing costs include tires, brakes, fluids, and routine inspections; while these are standard for most family SUVs, keeping up with maintenance is a key factor in long-term reliability.

Overall, owners who adhere to the recommended maintenance schedule and address recalls promptly tend to report steady reliability and fewer unexpected repair bills over the vehicle’s lifespan.

What to check when buying a used 2019 Highlander

If you’re evaluating a used 2019 Highlander, use this checklist to verify reliability and condition before purchase.

1. Review the complete maintenance and recall history, and confirm all recalls were completed with records from the seller or a dealer.


2. Inspect essential components: brakes, tires, suspension, and steering for even wear and signs of wear that could indicate alignment or component issues.


3. Test drive to assess transmission behavior, throttle response, and any hesitation or shudder that could indicate drivetrain concerns.


4. Check for a clean title and verify the vehicle history report for prior accidents, flood damage, or frame concerns.


5. Consider a pre-purchase inspection by a qualified mechanic to identify hidden wear or upcoming maintenance needs.

Following this checklist helps you avoid common used-car pitfalls and better gauge whether a particular 2019 Highlander will deliver the reliability you expect.

Bottom line

For most buyers, the 2019 Toyota Highlander offers a compelling blend of reliability, practicality, and resale value in a three-row SUV. While no used car is without risk, Toyota’s reputation for durability and a strong service network contribute to a favorable ownership experience when the vehicle has been properly maintained and thoroughly inspected before purchase.

Summary

The 2019 Highlander remains a strong pick for reliability within its class, supported by Toyota’s durability and positive independent reliability signals. Prospective buyers should verify maintenance and recall compliance, consider the drivetrain option that best fits their needs (gasoline vs. hybrid), and perform a thorough pre-purchase inspection to maximize long-term reliability. In short, a well-maintained 2019 Highlander can be a durable, economical choice in the used-SUV market.

Which year of Toyota Highlander is the most reliable?

The most reliable Toyota Highlander years are often cited as 2008 and the later years in the 2017-2019 and 2020-present generations. The 2008 model is the first year of the reliable second generation and offers solid construction, while the 2017-2019 models were refreshed with modern safety features and have strong reliability. The most recent generation (2020-present) also receives high marks, though data is still emerging. 
Most reliable model years

• 2008: This is often named the most reliable model year, as it launched the durable second generation with a strong V6 engine and significant improvements in comfort and technology. 
• 2017-2019: These model years are part of the third generation and are known for excellent reliability and longevity. The 2017 refresh added standard safety and driver-assistance features. 
• 2020-present: The fourth generation, which began in 2020, is currently seen as very reliable, with some sources calling it the best overall. However, some specific issues like bumper detachment have been noted in certain recalls. 
• 2023-2025: Newer models in the current generation are also rated highly for reliability, with some newer models like the 2023 Hybrid and 2024 Hybrid also receiving positive reliability predictions. 

Model years to approach with caution

• 2001 and 2005: These first-generation models are reportedly more prone to costly issues and are best avoided if possible. 
• 2010-2012: This period had some design and durability issues, and the models are generally less durable than the years before or after. 

How reliable is a 2019 Toyota Highlander?

The 2019 Toyota Highlander has a 3 years / 36,000 miles basic warranty and 3 recalls. RepairPal gives it a reliability rating of 4 out of 5, ranks it #6 out of 32 among Midsize SUVs.

Which Toyota Highlander to stay away from?

You should avoid the 2003, 2008, 2014, and 2015 model years of the Toyota Highlander due to common issues like engine problems in the 2003, and transmission glitches in the 2008 and 2015 models. Other years to be cautious with are 2009, 2010, and 2020, which had a higher number of recalls or transmission and software issues.
 
Years to avoid

• 2003: Engine overheating and the possibility of needing a costly engine block swap. 
• 2008: Significant issues with the braking system and a high number of recalls and complaints. 
• 2009 and 2010: A high number of recalls and complaints, particularly concerning the braking system. 
• 2014 and 2015: These years had early issues with transmission glitches and technology problems. 
• 2020: This model year experienced some transmission and software problems. 

Other considerations

• 2021: Reports of transmission failures. 
• 2023: In the non-hybrid, the turbocharged engine had issues with acceleration and the infotainment system could be unreliable. 
• 2024: Reports of issues with the infotainment system, a noisy engine, and hesitation. 

How long will a 2019 Toyota Highlander last?

A 2019 Toyota Highlander's life expectancy is between 200,000 and 300,000 miles or 10-15 years when properly maintained. With diligent care, some owners may even exceed 300,000 miles. The specific lifespan depends heavily on factors like maintenance history, driving conditions, and individual vehicle care. 
Factors influencing life expectancy

• Maintenance: Following the recommended service schedule is crucial for longevity. This includes regular oil changes, fluid flushes (like for the transmission and axles), and addressing issues like the fuel pump recall. 
• Driving conditions: The lifespan can be affected by the type of driving. Consistent highway driving is generally easier on a vehicle than stop-and-go city traffic. 
• Repairs and recalls: Promptly addressing any necessary repairs or recall work can prevent minor issues from becoming major, costly problems later on. 

What to consider

• Used vehicles: When buying a used 2019 Highlander, look for a complete service history to ensure it has been well-maintained. Ask about the status of the transmission fluid and if a drain and fill has been performed. 
• Reliability: The Highlander is a reliable vehicle with an average reliability rating of 4 out of 5 from sources like Edmunds. However, specific years have been linked to certain issues, so it's good to be aware of those.