What are the cons of the 2023 Crosstrek?

At a glance, the 2023 Crosstrek remains a strong all‑wheel‑drive compact, but it carries several notable drawbacks. The core disadvantages cited by reviewers center on power, ride refinement, cargo and interior practicality, and technology depth. This article breaks down those issues to help readers weigh the trade‑offs.

The Crosstrek's strengths—standard all‑wheel drive, off‑road capability, compact size for city use—come with compromises. Critics point to a comparatively weak base powertrain for highway use, a drone-prone CVT under load, tighter cargo space than some rivals, a ride that can feel firm on rough pavement, and interior tech and materials that lag behind class leaders. These factors tend to matter most to buyers who value acceleration, cargo flexibility, or cutting‑edge tech, rather than basic AWD capability.

Power and performance

Reviewers frequently highlight the Crosstrek’s engine and transmission as the first area where the model shows its limits. The following points summarize the most common concerns about how the Crosstrek moves.

• The base 2.0-liter engine can feel underpowered during highway merging and when climbing grades, making acceleration feel leisurely.


• The continuously variable transmission (CVT) often produces a drone or rubbery feel when you push the throttle hard, which can lessen driving refinement.


• Overall performance is adequate for city commuting and light cruising, but those who want brisk acceleration or confident passing power may wish for a stronger setup or a higher-trim engine option.

In short, the Crosstrek trades sportiness for efficiency and traction, which is a deliberate choice for many buyers but a drawback for those who prize quick highway performance.

Ride, handling and refinement

Beyond straight-line power, how the Crosstrek rides and handles is another common area of criticism. The following points describe what tends to stand out in reviews.

• Ride quality can feel firm or unsettled on rough pavement, with more impact and chatter than some rivals.


• Road and wind noise can intrude at higher speeds, diminishing cabin quietness on long trips.


• Handling is competent but not particularly engaging; body roll and a lack of steering precision can be noticeable in spirited driving.

For buyers who prioritize a plush, quiet ride or sporty handling, these traits may tilt the balance toward competitors with softer tuning or sharper dynamics.

Interior space and practicality

Practicality is a key selling point for the Crosstrek, but some buyers will encounter limitations inside and in cargo layout. Here are the principal concerns cited by reviewers.

• Cargo space behind the rear seats is modest for a compact SUV, and interior cargo access can feel tight compared with some rivals.


• Interior materials and fit‑and‑finish, especially in lower trims, may come across as subdued or cheaper relative to some competitors in the class.


• Rear‑seat headroom and overall rear space can be tight for taller passengers, particularly with the roofline that tucks down toward the rear.

These factors matter to families or frequent cargo haulers who rely on flexible space and a more premium feel inside the cabin.

Technology and safety features

Technology should add convenience, but in the 2023 Crosstrek some reviewers find the setup lagging behind top rivals. The main points are summarized here.

• The infotainment system can feel dated or slow to respond, with a touchscreen that some users find less intuitive than those in competing crossovers.


• Base trims may have fewer standard tech or driver-assistance features, pushing buyers toward higher trims for more complete suites of safety and convenience tech.


• Smartphone integration (Apple CarPlay and Android Auto) is available, but some owners report occasional quirks or connectivity hiccups depending on software updates and device.

For shoppers who expect the latest in cabin tech and driver aids at every trim level, the Crosstrek’s tech gap can be a deciding factor.

Value and ownership considerations

Price and ownership dynamics factor into how the Crosstrek stacks up against rivals. Here are the common value-related concerns noted by reviewers.

• Higher trims unlock more features, but the incremental cost can be significant, raising the price entry barrier for tech and comfort upgrades.


• Compared with some compact SUVs, the Crosstrek may offer less interior space, refinement, or engine power at a similar price point, which can affect perceived value.

For buyers prioritizing a spacious, quiet, and highly polished interior, the Crosstrek’s value proposition may be weaker than some rivals—though it remains compelling for those who want standard AWD and true off-road capability at a relatively approachable price.

Summary

The 2023 Subaru Crosstrek presents a compelling package for shoppers who want standard all‑wheel drive, a versatile compact footprint, and off‑road capability. Its most notable drawbacks—an underpowered base engine with a drone‑prone CVT, a firmer ride with more road noise, tighter cargo and interior space, and infotainment/tech that can feel dated—shape the buying decision for those who crave acceleration, luxurious interior appointments, or the latest cabin tech. If AWD versatility and practicality are your top priorities, the Crosstrek remains a strong choice; if you value blistering performance, a roomier cargo area, or cutting‑edge tech at the same price, you may want to explore rivals or higher trims within Subaru’s lineup.

What year to avoid a Subaru Crosstrek?

You should consider avoiding the 2016 and 2018 Subaru Crosstrek models due to drivetrain and oil consumption issues, respectively. The 2013-2017 first generation may also have issues, while the 2019 model is noted for numerous recalls and complaints, with the 2024 model being too new to have a long-term reliability record. 
Model years to be cautious with

• 2016: Reported issues with the CVT transmission, leading to vibrations and other performance problems. 
• 2018: A high number of complaints related to excessive oil consumption from the 2.0L engine. 
• 2019: Faced numerous recalls, primarily due to ECM software issues causing unexpected engine stalls. 
• 2013-2017: This first-generation period includes models that may have early-adopter issues, such as oil consumption and other problems. 
• 2024: While the new generation has potential, it is too early to have a comprehensive reliability history, and some owners report issues with in-car electronics and poor gas mileage. 

Why these years are problematic

• 2016: The CVT transmission problems are a significant concern, impacting the driving experience. 
• 2018: The oil consumption issue could lead to costly engine damage if not monitored and maintained diligently. 
• 2019: The engine stall issues and frequent recalls make this a year to be wary of. 
• 2013-2017: Early years of any new generation can have design and manufacturing issues that are corrected in later model years. 
• 2024: As the first year of a new generation, it may have initial issues that are not yet apparent, though this is a general concern for any newly designed vehicle. 

What are the cons of the Subaru Crosstrek 2023?

Review Summary
There are also concerns about the front seats, entertainment system, and the EyeSight safety system. While most owners are satisfied, a minority express disappointment with the overall quality and value proposition, citing problems like rattling noises, chipping paint, and rapid depreciation.

Which is better, the Toyota RAV4 or the Subaru Crosstrek?

The better SUV depends on your priorities: choose the Toyota RAV4 for more power, greater interior and cargo space, and a strong reputation for reliability. The Subaru Crosstrek is the better choice for standard all-wheel drive, off-road capability, a lower starting price, and a more modern interior design. 
This video compares the Toyota RAV4 and Subaru Crosstrek to help you decide which one is right for you: 59sAutomotive Anonymous YouTube · Jan 12, 2025
Toyota RAV4

• Performance: Offers a more powerful engine with quicker acceleration and slightly better fuel economy, especially in the hybrid model. 
• Space: Provides more interior space for passengers and a significantly larger cargo area. 
• Reliability: Has a stronger reputation for long-term reliability. 

Subaru Crosstrek

• Standard AWD: Comes standard with Symmetrical All-Wheel Drive, while the RAV4 requires a higher trim for AWD. 
• Off-road capability: Features higher ground clearance and standard off-road features like X-MODE and a higher ride height, making it better for trails and rough terrain. 
• Value: Has a lower starting price, which can be more budget-friendly. 
• Interior: Features a more modern design with a large vertical touchscreen, though the materials may feel less premium than the RAV4. 

What are the downsides of a Subaru Crosstrek?

Downsides of the Subaru Crosstrek include poor acceleration in the base engine, potential issues with the CVT and electrical systems, and a lack of cabin sound insulation. Other concerns involve easily chipped paint, fragile windshields, and limited cargo and interior space compared to larger vehicles.
 
Performance and mechanical issues

• Underpowered engine: The base 2.0-liter engine can feel sluggish, especially when merging or passing on highways. 
• CVT concerns: Some owners have reported premature wear, shuddering, or delayed acceleration from the Continuously Variable Transmission (CVT). 
• Excessive oil consumption: Older models have been noted for excessive oil consumption, requiring more frequent top-offs. 
• Steering and handling: Some earlier models have been criticized for handling issues, including fishtailing or pulling to one side. 

Electrical and technology problems 

• Infotainment glitches: Issues such as slow response times, screen freezing, Bluetooth connectivity problems, and unresponsiveness have been reported.
• Electrical malfunctions: Some models have experienced electrical problems with instrument panels affecting driver-assist features or infotainment systems. 

Body and interior complaints

• Poor sound insulation: The cabin is not well-insulated, leading to significant road, wind, and engine noise at various speeds. 
• Fragile paint and windshields: The paint can easily chip, and the windshields are prone to cracking from minor impacts. 
• Limited space: As a subcompact SUV, the cargo and interior space can feel cramped for families or those with a lot of gear. 

Other potential downsides

• High replacement costs: Issues like a cracked windshield with the EyeSight system require expensive recalibration upon replacement. 
• Overly sensitive driver-assist features: Some owners find the driver-assistance systems to be overly sensitive and disable them.