Home FAQ

What are the disadvantages of the Honda Pilot?

The Honda Pilot is a popular midsize SUV known for its spacious interior, comfortable ride, and reliable performance. However, like any vehicle, the Pilot has its fair share of drawbacks. In this article, we'll explore the key disadvantages of the Honda Pilot to help you make an informed decision when considering this SUV.

Fuel Economy

One of the primary downsides of the Honda Pilot is its relatively poor fuel economy. The Pilot's EPA-estimated fuel economy ranges from 19 to 22 mpg in the city and 27 to 28 mpg on the highway, depending on the trim level and drivetrain configuration. This is lower than many of its competitors in the midsize SUV segment, which can achieve up to 26 mpg in the city and 32 mpg on the highway.

Handling and Maneuverability

The Honda Pilot's size and weight can make it feel less agile and maneuverable than some smaller SUVs. The Pilot's large turning radius and bulky dimensions can make it challenging to navigate tight spaces, such as crowded parking lots or city streets. Additionally, the Pilot's soft suspension tuning and body roll can contribute to a less responsive and engaging driving experience.

Cargo Space Limitations

While the Honda Pilot offers a spacious interior with seating for up to eight passengers, its cargo space is not as generous as some of its competitors. With all three rows of seats in use, the Pilot offers just 16.5 cubic feet of cargo space, which is on the lower end for a midsize SUV. Folding down the third-row seats increases the cargo capacity to 46.8 cubic feet, but this is still less than what some rivals offer.

Pricing and Value

The Honda Pilot is generally priced higher than many of its competitors in the midsize SUV segment. The base model Pilot starts at around $32,000, while top-trim models can exceed $50,000. While the Pilot is known for its quality and reliability, some buyers may find that the price tag doesn't align with the overall value proposition when compared to other midsize SUVs.

Conclusion

The Honda Pilot is a well-rounded midsize SUV with many strengths, but it also has some notable disadvantages. From its relatively poor fuel economy and handling limitations to its cargo space constraints and higher pricing, the Pilot may not be the best choice for everyone. Ultimately, it's important to carefully consider your specific needs and priorities when evaluating the Honda Pilot against its competitors in the midsize SUV market.

What Honda Pilot to stay away from?

Honda Pilots to avoid include the 2003, 2004, 2005, 2011, 2016, and 2017 model years due to significant issues like transmission failures, engine problems, and electrical issues. Specifically, early models (2003–2005) were known for transmission defects, while the 2016 model saw high complaint numbers for transmission, engine, and electrical systems following a redesign. The 2017 model also had a high number of complaints, and certain models from 2008–2014 had engine problems.

This video explains which Honda Pilot models to avoid: 52sCar ComfyYouTube · Sep 26, 2025
Honda Pilot model years to avoid

2003-2005: These models are known for severe transmission problems, including torque converter failure and leaks.
2011: This year is frequently cited for having major transmission and electrical issues.
2016: Considered one of the most problematic years due to a high number of transmission, engine, and electrical complaints. The redesign of this generation led to several issues, including engine stop-start system problems.
2017: This model year also received a high number of complaints from owners.
2019-2020: Some owners have reported problems with the navigation/entertainment system, instrument panel, and various electrical issues.

Other years with known issues

2008–2014: Some models in this range had issues with the V6 engine, including problems with piston rings.
2023–2025: Some of these recent models are subject to recalls and potential issues related to the fuel injection system, which may cause engine stalling or a loss of power.

What to do when buying a used Honda Pilot

Always check for recalls and any completed fixes.
Review the vehicle's maintenance history to ensure it was properly maintained.
Look for a vehicle with a good service record, especially with regular oil changes and transmission fluid services.
Consider purchasing a certified pre-owned (CPO) vehicle with an extended warranty for extra peace of mind.

What are the best and worst years for Honda Pilots?

The best years for the Honda Pilot are generally considered to be 2006-2008, 2019, and 2021, while the worst years to avoid are 2003, 2005, 2011, 2016, and 2017 due to common transmission, electrical, or airbag issues.
You can watch this video to learn about the best and worst years for the Honda Pilot: 56sCar ComfyYouTube · Sep 26, 2025
Best years

2006-2008: These models are part of the first generation and are praised for their solid construction and reliability.
2019: While the entire fourth generation is a good option, some sources single out the 2019 model for its reliability and efficiency.
2021: This year is recommended by CarGurus.com and receives a "recommended" label from Consumer Reports.

Worst years to avoid

2003: The first model year, it had numerous owner complaints, primarily concerning the transmission and interior.
2005: Continued to have recurring transmission flaws, according to Capital One.
2011: Often cited as a year to avoid due to various reported issues, from CoPilot for Car Shopping.
2016: Had the highest number of complaints with the NHTSA and is frequently listed among the worst years by various sources.
2017: Also included in lists of problematic years by sources like AGT Europe Automotive Import SA.

What are the negatives of a Honda Pilot?

One of the big disadvantages of the Honda Pilot is the lack of hybrid trim options. With such a large SUV, the fuel efficiency ratings aren't great, though they are competitive with other gasoline-powered SUVs. The 2023 AWD Pilot has a fuel efficiency rating of 21 combined city/highway mpg.

What is the most common problem with the Honda Pilot?

Common problems reported for the Honda Pilot include transmission failures, excessive oil consumption, and various engine and electrical issues like fuel injector failures. Other frequent complaints involve peeling paint and brake problems, such as warped rotors and issues with the Collision Mitigation Braking System.

This video discusses common issues with the 2016-2018 Honda Pilot: 1mBCauto_YouTube · Aug 2, 2022
Engine and electrical problems

Excessive oil consumption: Some models consume oil at a higher-than-normal rate.
Fuel injector failure: This is a common cause of engine issues.
Engine stalling or misfiring: Can be linked to problems like carbon buildup or defective fuel injectors.
Electrical issues: Includes problems with the infotainment system, various warning lights, and an overheating wire harness that can cause low beams to fail.
Emissions system problems: Owners have reported issues with the check engine light and other components.

Transmission issues

Major transmission failures: Some model years have a higher incidence of major transmission problems, including complete failure and the need for replacement.

This video discusses common issues with the 2009-2015 Honda Pilot: 55sMJ100kYouTube · Sep 30, 2025
Body and brake issues

Peeling paint: This is a frequently mentioned aesthetic complaint on certain models.
Warped brake rotors: Can cause vibration when braking.
Brake system faults: Including instances of the Collision Mitigation Braking System activating incorrectly.

Kevin Bennett

Company Owner

Kevin Bennet is the founder and owner of Kevin's Autos, a leading automotive service provider in Australia. With a deep commitment to customer satisfaction and years of industry expertise, Kevin uses his blog to answer the most common questions posed by his customers. From maintenance tips to troubleshooting advice, Kevin's articles are designed to empower drivers with the knowledge they need to keep their vehicles running smoothly and safely.