What year of Honda Pilot is the best?

In general, there isn’t a single “best” year for the Honda Pilot; many buyers find the 2016–2018 models offer the strongest reliability and value, while the newest generation (2023–present) delivers the latest safety tech and space. Your ideal year depends on budget, desired features, and how important modern comforts are to you.

The Honda Pilot has evolved through four generations since its 2003 introduction. This article weighs reliability, safety equipment, fuel economy, and ownership costs across key model years to help readers decide which year best fits their priorities.

How to judge the best year for you

Choosing the best Pilot year is a balance of reliability history, feature set, and long-term ownership costs. The ranges below are commonly cited by buyers and reviewers as solid starting points, with notes on what makes each period appealing or worth avoiding for specific needs.

Before diving into the list, here’s a quick guide to the model-year ranges that are generally considered strong choices for most buyers.



• 2016–2018: The mid-cycle refresh in the current generation brought improved materials, ride quality, and safety tech. Widely regarded as a sweet spot for reliability, practicality, and value in the used market.


• 2019–2020: More standard safety features across trims and updated infotainment; good balance of modern tech and still-competitive pricing for a still-young model year.


• 2021–2022: Later 3rd-generation models with ongoing refinements and equipment updates; solid option if you want newer features without paying the latest-generation premium.


• 2023–present: The newest generation offers the latest styling, space, and safety technology; ideal for buyers who want current tech and a longer remaining warranty, but often at a higher purchase price.

Concluding this section, the best year for you hinges on whether you prioritize value and proven reliability (lean toward 2016–2018), modern tech and safety (look at 2019–2022), or the newest design and features (consider 2023–present).

Generation-by-generation snapshot

First generation (2003–2008): early practicality, higher maintenance risk

The original Pilot offered roomy seating and straightforward utility, but these early models are now the oldest option on the market. They tend to show higher maintenance costs and fewer modern safety features compared with later generations. If shopping in this range, it’s essential to verify comprehensive service records and a meticulous pre-purchase inspection.

Second generation (2009–2015): improvements with some reliability caveats

This generation refined interior space and ride comfort and improved overall practicality. Reliability is generally acceptable, but buyers should be mindful of individual vehicle history and any known recalls. A well-maintained example from this era can still offer solid value, especially at lower prices.

Third generation (2016–2022): widely considered the reliability and value sweet spot

The 2016 redesign brought a more modern interior, better safety equipment, and improved ride dynamics. Used Pilots from 2016–2018 are often recommended for their balance of features and dependable performance. Later 2019–2022 models added more standard tech and refined amenities, keeping them competitive in price and capability.

Fourth generation (2023–present): latest tech and biggest updates

The current generation emphasizes space, modern design, and an array of updated safety and infotainment features. It’s the best choice for buyers who want the newest technology and longest potential warranty coverage, but it usually carries a higher upfront cost and, in some cases, earlier-model-year quirks typical of a new platform. Thorough inspection and a careful test drive are advised.

What to look for when buying used Honda Pilot

When shopping for a used Pilot, a structured checklist helps safeguard against common issues and ensures you’re getting a solid, long-lived vehicle.

Before listing the checks, remember that a pre-purchase inspection and a VIN-based recall/history check are essential steps for any used car purchase.



• Pre-purchase history and recalls: Pull a vehicle history report and confirm all recalls have been addressed; verify maintenance records and service milestones.


• Powertrain and transmission: Listen for unusual noises, check for smooth shifting, and review service records for transmission-related concerns that have appeared in certain model years.


• Electrical and tech: Test infotainment systems, Bluetooth, navigation, and driver-assist features (lane-keeping, adaptive cruise, collision mitigation) for proper operation.


• Suspension, steering, and brakes: Check for uneven tire wear, abnormal clunks, or pulling; inspect suspension bushings and braking components.


• Interior and seating: Examine the condition of seats, carpets, and trim; ensure climate control works in all modes, and check for obvious wear that could indicate heavy use.


• Ownership costs and reliability history: Compare projected maintenance costs, fuel economy, and typical repair frequency across years to gauge long-term ownership value.

Concluding this buying guide, a well-maintained used Pilot from 2016–2018 often offers the best balance of reliability and cost, while newer models deliver the latest features at a higher price. Regardless of year, a professional inspection and a thorough test drive are key to a wise purchase.

Summary

The Honda Pilot remains a strong three-row SUV option across its generations, with the 2016–2018 models frequently cited as the most reliable and cost-effective used buys. If you want the newest features and the latest safety tech, the 2023–present generation is compelling, but it comes at a higher price and potential early-year quirks. Your best year depends on budget, desired technology, and how important long-term maintenance costs are to you. Always check recall history, obtain a full vehicle inspection, and weigh ownership costs over the life of the vehicle to determine the best match for your needs.

What year is the Honda Pilot the most reliable?

The most reliable Honda Pilot years are often cited as the final model years of a generation, specifically 2008, 2015, and 2022. Other particularly reliable years include 2014, 2017–2021, and 2006-2007. Generally, the second-generation models (2009-2015) are considered a good choice, especially the 2015 model, and the later years of the third generation (2017-2021) also have fewer reported issues. 
Most reliable model years

• 2008: The last model year of the first generation, it benefited from several updates and had few reported problems. 
• 2015: The final model year of the second generation, it was refined and is often praised for reliability. 
• 2017–2021: These years in the third generation have fewer complaints than earlier models in the same generation. The 2018 model is a standout, especially with the six-speed automatic transmission. 
• 2022: This is another model year that receives high marks for reliability. 

Years to approach with caution

• 2016: This model year is often singled out as having more issues than other third-generation models. 

Tips for buying

• Consider the generation: The second generation (2009-2015) is generally considered reliable, especially the 2015 model. The third generation (2016-2022) is also reliable, though some specific years are better than others. 
• Check the transmission: The 2018 and later models that use a six-speed automatic transmission are considered more reliable. 
• Inspect the vehicle: Regardless of the model year, always get a vehicle history report and a pre-purchase inspection to ensure the car has been well-maintained. 

What years did Honda Pilot have transmission problems?

The main years for Honda Pilot transmission problems are 2003, 2005, and 2016, with the 2003 model being particularly prone to transmission failure. While the 2003 and 2005 years are known for significant issues, the 2016 model also has many owner complaints related to its new transmission, as well as engine and electrical problems. Other models like 2017-2020 have been investigated for issues with the 9-speed transmission and the stop-start system. 
This video demonstrates a common Honda Pilot transmission issue and explains what to do: 58sAleksandr UsovichYouTube · Aug 27, 2021
Specific model years with notable transmission issues

• 2003: This year is infamous for transmission failures, which can be very expensive to fix or replace. 
• 2005: Also experienced transmission problems, with owners reporting issues. 
• 2016: This model year saw a high number of complaints, including a new transmission, engine problems, and electrical system issues. 
• 2017-2020: The 6-speed transmission in some of these models, and the 9-speed in others, can have issues, and the stop-start system has also been a source of complaints. 

What to keep in mind when buying an older Honda Pilot

• Check maintenance records: Properly maintained transmissions are less likely to have problems. 
• Consider the model year: 2003, 2005, and 2016 are known problematic years. Newer models (2017-2020) may have issues with the stop-start system. 
• Get a pre-purchase inspection: Have a mechanic thoroughly inspect the vehicle, paying close attention to the transmission, before buying. 
• Be aware of recall status: Check if any recalls have been performed, especially for models like 2016, which had several recalls. 

What Honda Pilot to stay away from?

Honda Pilot years to avoid include 2003, 2005, 2016, and 2017 due to major transmission, engine, and electrical issues. Other problematic years include 2004 and 2011, and the 2016-2020 models were also investigated for problems with the engine's stop-start system. It's also wise to be cautious of 2008-2014 models, which may have engine ring problems. 
This video explains which years of Honda Pilot to avoid and which are the best to buy: 52sCar ComfyYouTube · Sep 26, 2025
Specific years to avoid and their common problems:

• 2003, 2005: Primarily plagued by transmission problems, including torque converter failure. 
• 2004, 2011: Both have been cited as problematic years. 
• 2016: Had a high number of complaints and was the first year of a new generation, leading to multiple issues including transmission problems, engine issues, electrical malfunctions, and problems with the stop-start system. 
• 2017: Faced issues such as transmission and electrical problems. 
• 2016-2019: These years, particularly the 2016, had numerous owner complaints and official recalls, including issues with electrical systems, navigation, and the stop-start system. 
• 2008-2014: Certain models from these years can have problems with the V6 engine, specifically with piston rings. 
• 2025: While newer, some 2025 models have been recalled for issues with the third-row seat belt assembly. 
• 2023-2024: Also have a recall for potential fuel leaks from the fuel filler neck tube. 

What to consider before buying

• Used models: If buying used, look for meticulous service records, especially for oil changes and transmission services. 
• Recalls: Always check for open recalls on any model year you are considering. 
• Repairs: Some years had issues that were addressed through recalls, while others may require more extensive or costly repairs if problems have occurred. 
• Warranty: Consider purchasing a used model with a warranty or buying a certified pre-owned (CPO) vehicle with an extended Honda warranty. 

Which is the best Honda Pilot to buy?

The best Honda Pilot model years are often considered to be 2015, 2022, and 2008 for overall reliability and fewer problems. For the best value, the 2009-2015 second-generation models are a great option, while the 2018 is praised for technology and versatility. Newer fourth-generation models offer the most modern features.
 
By year and generation

• 2015: Frequently cited as one of the most reliable models in the second generation, known for durability and minimal reported issues. 
• 2022: A highly reliable model, receiving the "Seal of Awesome" for reliability from CarComplaints.com. 
• 2008: A first-generation model that was a best-seller and is highly rated for reliability, though some owners experienced VCM (Variable Cylinder Management) system issues and had to address airbag recalls. 
• 2018: Praised for its technology and family-friendly design, with the Touring trim being a notable option for its features. 

By generation and value

• Best value: The second generation (2009-2015) models offer a good balance of space and modern features without the higher price of newer generations.
• Newest technology: For the most up-to-date technology and features, consider the newer fourth-generation models.
• Budget-friendly: The first-generation Pilot can be a fine choice on a tight budget, but it is recommended to have a mechanic thoroughly inspect the transmission and radiator. 

To consider when buying

• Front-wheel drive (FWD) vs. all-wheel drive (AWD): Opt for AWD only if you live in an area with snow. FWD models are more fuel-efficient and have fewer parts that could require repair. 
• Trims: If you want a more upscale option, look for higher trims like the EX-L or Elite, which add features like leather seats and a Head-Up Display. 
• Problematic years: It is best to avoid the 2016 model year, as well as earlier models like 2003, 2004, 2005, 2011, and 2017, which had reported issues with transmissions, airbags, and other components.