Do subarus last as long as Toyotas?
In short, both brands can reach high mileages with proper maintenance, but Toyotas generally have a broader track record for long-term reliability and lower ownership costs. Subarus can also reach 200,000 miles and beyond, particularly in modern AWD models, with diligent service.
Overview: longevity expectations by brand
Understanding how the two brands compare in long-term durability involves looking at reliability surveys, owner data, and common maintenance needs across model years.
Here is a concise snapshot based on recent reliability studies and owner experiences:
- Toyota typically posts higher reliability scores and has a long history of 200k-mile-plus success with minimal major repairs.
- Subaru also shows strong durability, especially in AWD models like the Outback and Forester, though some generations needed more frequent maintenance or repairs than their Toyota counterparts.
- Maintenance costs can differ, with Toyotas often showing lower average long-term maintenance costs compared to Subarus in similar segments.
- Model-year and design changes matter; newer Subarus have addressed many older concerns and show improving reliability, especially in engine and CVT technology.
Bottom line: Toyotas generally edge Subarus in broad reliability metrics, but Subarus can deliver comparable longevity with proper care.
Model-year and mechanical specifics
Details about how engine design, drivetrain and age influence long-term success for each brand.
Subaru-specific considerations
Subaru engines and drivetrains require particular maintenance discipline. Historically, some 2.5L engines faced head gasket issues, and AWD systems add mechanical complexity. In recent years, Subaru has introduced more robust engines and updated transmissions to boost durability.
Before listing, note common maintenance realities for Subarus:
- Head gasket vulnerabilities are more likely in certain older 2.5L engines; proactive cooling system and regular checks help mitigate risk.
- CVTs (where used) show variable reliability depending on model year and service history; many owners report long life with proper maintenance.
- Regular oil changes, timing belt/chain maintenance, and cooling system service are critical for longevity.
- All-wheel-drive components add durability benefits in poor weather but higher maintenance costs.
Conclusion: with attentive maintenance and choosing a well-documented model year, Subarus can achieve high mileages comparable to Toyotas.
Toyota-specific considerations
Toyotas are renowned for durable engines, straightforward maintenance, and strong long-term performance. While no brand is immune to issues, many Toyota models routinely reach 200k miles with routine care.
Before listing, note key reliability drivers for Toyotas:
- Engine designs emphasize longevity; many Toyota engines are known for reaching high mileages with routine service.
- Transmission reliability is strong across many generations, though some earlier models required careful maintenance or faced recalls.
- Maintenance costs tend to be predictable and often lower than the average for many non-Toyota brands.
- Quality control, dealer/service network, and resale value contribute to the brand’s reputation for long-term durability.
Conclusion: Toyota's reliability profile remains robust, and its vehicles often require fewer major repairs over time compared with many peers, including some Subarus.
Bottom line for buyers
For buyers targeting high-mileage longevity, prioritize documented maintenance history, model-year reliability notes, and service records as much as brand reputation. A well-maintained Subaru or Toyota can last for decades, though the odds of reaching very high mileages are typically higher across the Toyota lineup.
Summary
Both Subaru and Toyota produce durable vehicles capable of long lifespans with proper care. Toyotas generally offer a wider proven track record for reliability and lower long-term ownership costs, while Subarus deliver strong longevity in all-wheel-drive models and recent generations. The best approach is to evaluate specific models, check maintenance history, and choose a well-documented vehicle regardless of brand. With good maintenance, either brand can comfortably exceed 200,000 miles.
Is Subaru more expensive to repair than Toyota?
Yes, Subarus are generally more expensive to repair than Toyotas, with average annual maintenance and repair costs for Subarus being higher than for Toyotas. This is due to factors like generally lower reliability for Subarus and more complex or labor-intensive repairs for certain Subaru models, particularly those with boxer engines. Toyota parts are also often cheaper, and more mechanics are familiar with them.
Factors contributing to higher Subaru repair costs
- Lower reliability: Subaru has a lower average reliability score than Toyota.
- Higher annual costs: CarEdge estimates higher average annual costs for Subarus ($617) compared to Toyota ($441).
- More complex engines: Subaru's boxer engines can be more time-consuming and costly to perform maintenance on, such as oil changes and spark plug replacements.
- Drivetrain components: Subaru's all-wheel drive system can lead to more frequent wear on parts like CV axles and wheel bearings, as well as the cost of replacing four tires at once.
- Costly major repairs: Some older Subaru models have known issues, such as head gasket problems around 100,000 miles.
Why Toyota repairs are often less expensive
- Higher reliability: Toyota vehicles generally have lower repair frequency and severity.
- More common parts: Toyota parts are widely available and less expensive.
- Widespread familiarity: More mechanics are familiar with repairing Toyotas, which can lead to lower labor costs.
- Simpler design: Many Toyota models are front-wheel drive, which reduces the number of drivetrain components that require maintenance.
Which car is better, a Toyota or a Subaru?
In conclusion, Toyota and Subaru both offer exceptional vehicles with a range of features and capabilities, Subaru stands out as the superior choice for drivers seeking a blend of safety, reliability, versatility, and value.
How long do Subarus last vs Toyota?
And, Toyota was awarded the most reliable brand at the 2021 Auto Trader New Car Awards. Also, Toyota's can last well past 300,000 miles (think of the million-mile Tundra), while Subaru typically lasts around 200,000 miles.
What is Subarus most common problem?
Subaru's most common problem: transmission failure
Transmission slipping: If your Subaru is shuddering when you accelerate, you might need to replace a solenoid (wire coil) in the engine.
