Is the 2016 Subaru Legacy a reliable car?

Yes—overall, the 2016 Subaru Legacy is considered a reliable used sedan, with standard all-wheel drive, strong safety credentials, and solid owner satisfaction. Reliability can vary based on how well the car has been maintained and how many miles it has, and some owners report CVT-related quirks as mileage climbs.

Reliability snapshot

The following points summarize why the 2016 Legacy is generally regarded as reliable, while also noting practical caveats for buyers and owners.

• Standard all-wheel drive across the lineup, providing enhanced traction and stability in various conditions.


• Strong safety ratings from major testing organizations, contributing to long-term value and peace of mind.


• Predictable maintenance needs for a mid-size sedan, with routine items like tires, brakes, and fluids driving ongoing costs.


• Solid interior quality and ride comfort, supporting durability for daily commuting and longer trips.


• Healthy resale value within the used-car market, helped by Subaru’s reputation for practicality and AWD capability.

Note: Individual results vary with mileage, climate, maintenance history, and how well the vehicle has been cared for over its life.

Common issues to watch for

While the 2016 Legacy generally performs well for its class, some ownership experiences and maintenance histories show potential trouble areas to inspect or inquire about before buying or driving a high-mileage example.

• CVT transmission behavior: Some owners report shifting irregularities or reluctance as mileage increases. If the car has a CVT, ensure it has a documented maintenance history and listen for unusual noises or surging during a test drive.


• Oil consumption and leaks: Occasional reports of oil consumption or small leaks exist in the broader Subaru lineup. Check for oil spots on the ground, inspect valve-cover gaskets, oil pan, and PCV system, and monitor oil level between changes.


• Engine health on the newer FA-series platform: While less prone to earlier head-gasket issues than older Subaru engines, any coolant or oil leaks should be investigated, and coolant levels should be monitored over time.


• Infotainment/electrical quirks: Some vehicles experience touchscreen or Bluetooth hiccups; make sure software updates have been applied and that all radios, navigation, and connectivity features function normally.


• Recall history and safety campaigns: Check the vehicle’s VIN for open recalls (airbags, fuel-system components, etc.) and confirm that any required recall work has been completed.

Concluding note: These items are not guaranteed problems in every car, but they represent the issues most commonly discussed by owners and service technicians. A thorough pre-purchase inspection and a review of service records can help you assess risk for a specific vehicle.

What to look for when buying a used 2016 Legacy

To maximize reliability and value, use this checklist when evaluating a used 2016 Legacy. The goal is to verify proper maintenance, confirm no unresolved recalls, and assess signs of typical wear for the model year.

• Complete maintenance history, especially regular oil changes and any CVT fluid changes as per Subaru’s schedule.


• VIN-based recall check to confirm open recalls have been addressed.


• Evidence of leak-free engine area and good cooling-system condition (hoses, radiator, and coolant level).


• Solid test-drive performance with smooth acceleration, proper CVT behavior, and no unusual vibrations or noises.


• Perfect or near-perfect tire condition and balanced wheel alignment to support the AWD system.


• Inspection for rust or corrosion on the undercarriage in regions with winter road salt exposure.

Concluding paragraph: A careful pre-purchase inspection by a qualified mechanic, paired with a clean maintenance log, is the most reliable way to determine whether a particular 2016 Legacy will be a dependable long-term partner.

Summary

The 2016 Subaru Legacy sits toward the reliable end of its class, thanks to AWD practicality, strong safety scores, and solid overall durability. As with any used car, reliability hinges on maintenance history, mileage, and how well issues like the CVT, oil leaks, and recalls have been addressed. If you prioritize a well-documented service history and a clean pre-purchase inspection, the 2016 Legacy can be a solid, value-oriented choice in the used-car market.

Is the 2016 Subaru Legacy reliable?

The 2016 Subaru Legacy is considered reliable by some sources, with high owner satisfaction ratings, but has some notable issues, including a below-average rating from J.D. Power. It has a good reputation for durability with proper maintenance, but some owners report common problems and there was a safety recall related to the steering column.
 
You can watch this video to learn about the features and performance of the 2016 Subaru Legacy: 1msavagegeeseYouTube · Jun 4, 2016
Positive aspects

• High owner satisfaction: Many owners report high satisfaction with the car's reliability and value, giving it a high-star rating on sites like Kelley Blue Book. 
• Reputation for durability: With proper maintenance, many Subaru Legacies can surpass 200,000 miles. 
• Strong owner reviews: Consumer Reports gives the Legacy line a "Very Good" reliability rating and a high owner satisfaction score, according to BestRide.com. 
• Safety and features: It is praised for its safety features, handling, and a comfortable cabin. 

Negative aspects

• Mixed official ratings: J.D. Power gives the 2016 model a below-average reliability rating, though Consumer Reports rates it positively. 
• Common issues: Some owners report common problems such as the check engine light coming on, vibration, and a bumpy ride. 
• Recalls: The 2016 Legacy has had recalls, including a significant safety recall for the steering column on certain models, notes Cars.com. 
• Maintenance is crucial: To achieve long-term reliability, consistent maintenance is essential, according to Huffines Subaru Corinth. 

What is the most reliable year for the Subaru Legacy?

The most reliable Subaru Legacy years include the 2018 model, and the redesign years like 2020 and newer, which have improved reliability. Older generations, like the first and second (pre-2010), are also considered reliable, but potential issues like head gasket problems need to be checked for, particularly on models with the older EJ25 engines. The 2014 model is also noted as a reliable option, while some models from 2016-2020 may have more complaints. 
This video discusses the reliability of Subaru Legacy models from 2020 to 2021: 1mCarLandTVYouTube · Apr 16, 2025
Recommended model years

• 2020 and newer: These are considered more reliable due to a significant redesign and updated technology. The 2020 model year is frequently cited as a good option, notes CoPilot for Car Shopping. 
• 2018: This is another standout year, with a high reliability rating from J.D. Power. 
• Pre-2010: Older models from the first and second generations are known for their strong reliability, especially those with the EJ22E engine. 
• 2014: This is another year that receives high marks for reliability from sources like J.D. Power and Consumer Reports. 

Years to be cautious about

• 2016-2020: Some models in this range may have a higher number of complaints, according to Jalopnik. 
• 2012-2013: Be cautious with these models, especially if the head gaskets have not been documented as changed. 
• 2010-2012: Some models from these years had head gasket issues, though the design was improved in later years. 

You can watch this video to learn about the pros and cons of buying a used Subaru Outback or Legacy: 55sMrSubaru1387YouTube · Feb 14, 2022
Important considerations

• Maintenance: How well a car has been maintained is the most significant factor in its reliability, regardless of the model year. 
• Engine: The EJ25 engine in some older models is more prone to head gasket failure than other engines. The newer FB25 and FA24 engines in more recent models are generally more reliable. 
• Transmission: If looking at a car with over 100,000 miles, check the clutch and slave cylinder on a manual transmission. 

How many miles does a 2016 Subaru Legacy last?

A 2016 Subaru Legacy can last over 200,000 miles, and its lifespan is highly dependent on proper maintenance, particularly with regard to the engine and its unique Boxer engine and AWD system. Key maintenance includes regular oil changes, timely transmission and differential fluid changes, and tire rotations. 
Factors affecting life expectancy

• Regular maintenance: Consistent adherence to the maintenance schedule is the most critical factor. This includes oil changes, checking fluids, and replacing key parts at the recommended intervals. 
• AWD system care: The all-wheel-drive system requires attention, especially if driven in severe conditions. Changing the differential and transfer case oils every 15,000 to 30,000 miles can help, and tire rotations every 4,000 miles can prevent uneven wear. 
• Driving habits: How the car is driven significantly impacts its longevity. Aggressive driving can lead to premature failure of components like the transmission. 
• Maintenance history: A vehicle with a documented service history is more likely to have been properly maintained, increasing the likelihood of a longer life. 

Estimated lifespan

• Engine: Subaru engines are known to last between 200,000 and 300,000 miles with proper care. 
• Vehicle: Many Legacy sedans easily surpass 200,000 miles, and some have reached over 250,000 miles with basic repairs. 

What is the most common problem with Subaru Legacy?

Top Subaru Legacy Problems

• Cooling System Problems Cause Head Gasket Failure.
• Subaru Front O2 Sensor Recall.
• Failure in ABS causes pump to run continuously and wear down battery.
• Failure in ABS causes pump to run continuously and wear down battery.
• Engine Oil May Leak From Camshaft/Crankshaft Front Seals.