What is the best year for a Toyota Highlander?

The best year for a Toyota Highlander depends on what you value most—reliability, safety, or the latest tech. In practice, many buyers consider 2009–2011, 2014–2016, and 2020–2023 as strong options, balancing proven reliability with practical features and modern safety gear.

This article examines Highlander generations to help you identify standout model years, what to watch for when shopping used, and how to weigh tradeoffs between older reliability and newer technology.

Overview of Highlander Generations and What Makes a Year Stand Out

Toyota launched the Highlander in 2001. The first generation (2001–2007) established the model as a dependable family SUV but showed aging design and some early-assembly quirks. The second generation (2008–2013) brought more refined engines, improved ride quality, and stronger reliability, making several years within this window popular choices for used buyers. The third generation (2014–2019) delivered a modern interior, better safety equipment, and stronger overall reliability, with mid-generation updates improving infotainment and driver aids. The fourth generation (2020–present) introduced a redesigned platform, more standard safety tech, and options like a hybrid powertrain, appealing to buyers seeking the latest features and efficiency.

Top Year Picks by Generation

Second generation (2008–2013)

These years are often highlighted by reviewers and owners for their balance of reliability, value, and features within the second generation.

• 2009 Highlander: widely regarded as a dependable choice with strong reliability history and good resale value.


• 2010 Highlander: solid overall performance, with continued reliability and a comfortable ride.


• 2011 Highlander: another strong all-around option, frequently recommended for its proven track record.

In this generation, these years are commonly cited as dependable picks for used buyers, especially when paired with a thorough maintenance history.

Third generation (2014–2019)

With a redesigned platform and updated safety tech, the third generation offers modern conveniences and improved build quality. Within this window, a few years are frequently cited as standout values.

• 2014 Highlander: first year of the new generation, with many new features but potential early-model quirks; still a solid option if well-maintained.


• 2015 Highlander: improved drivetrains and safety features; generally reliable and popular among buyers.


• 2016 Highlander: widely regarded as a sweet spot for value and reliability in the third generation.

These years are often recommended for buyers seeking a balance of modern design, safety, and long-term reliability in the third generation.

Fourth generation (2020–present)

The fourth generation brings the latest Toyota engineering, enhanced safety systems, and, in some trims, hybrid power. This makes the early- to mid-2020s particularly appealing for new-car reliability and modern tech in a used-buy context.

• 2020 Highlander: redesigned platform and new safety features; strong baseline reliability with the added benefit of recent updates.


• 2021 Highlander: refined infotainment and comfort features; generally favorable reliability scores.


• 2022–2023 Highlander: modern equipment and stable performance; good value as newer used options, often with updated driver aids.

For buyers prioritizing the latest tech and safety, these years offer the most complete equipment, with reliability continuing to be Toyota’s strong suit.

What to Watch When Buying a Used Highlander

When shopping across generations, a few checks help separate solid buys from problem vehicles. The following points cover common concerns and due diligence that can pay off regardless of year.

• Maintenance history: look for regular service, timely fluid changes, and records of timing belt/chain service where applicable.


• Transmission and drivetrain: ensure smooth shifting, no shuddering, slipping, or unexpected downshifts, particularly in older second- and third-generation models.


• Oil consumption and leaks: some engines in older Highlanders have been known to consume oil or develop leaks; verify oil level history and recent changes.


• Recalls and repairs: confirm all open recalls have been addressed and verify with the NHTSA or Toyota recall databases; ensure dealer-installed fix lists are complete.


• Electrical and HVAC systems: test the climate control, infotainment, power windows, and sensors to catch intermittent electrical issues common in aging vehicles.


• Rust and underbody wear: inspect for rust, frame rust, and corrosion, especially on higher‑mileage or earlier models.

Thorough pre-purchase inspection by a qualified mechanic is strongly recommended to confirm the condition of any used Highlander, regardless of year.

Safety and Reliability Ratings

Across generations, the Highlander has earned solid safety scores and strong reliability reputations. Newer generations tend to bring more advanced driver-assistance features as standard or optional equipment, along with improved crash-test performance and refined interiors. While each model year can vary based on maintenance history and specific builds, the model line as a whole remains a dependable choice in the midsize SUV segment.

How to Choose the Best Highlander Year for You

• Define your priorities: reliability, budget, safety tech, or the latest features?


• Set a budget that accounts for potential maintenance on older models versus the higher upfront cost of newer ones.


• Prioritize generations known for reliability and good maintenance histories, then narrow by the specific year’s records.


• Get a pre-purchase inspection and review the vehicle’s service records and recall history.


• Test-drive multiple years within your target range to compare ride quality, braking, and infotainment usability.

By aligning model-year choices with maintenance history and your priorities, you can find a Highlander that offers solid reliability and value.

Summary

There isn’t a single “best year” for the Toyota Highlander; the strongest used picks tend to cluster around 2009–2011 (second generation), 2014–2016 (third generation), and 2020–2023 (fourth generation). Each window brings a different balance of reliability, safety technology, and value. The key to success is a detailed service history, a thorough pre-purchase inspection, and shopping within a generation with proven reliability while prioritizing the specific features and budget you want. For most buyers, aiming for a well-documented, accident-free vehicle with complete recall repairs and a clean maintenance record will yield the most satisfaction, regardless of the exact year.

What is the most common problem with a Toyota Highlander?

The most common problem with the Toyota Highlander is a major oil leak and loss of oil pressure caused by a faulty VVT-i oil line. Other frequent issues include infrequent but noticeable interior rattles, especially from the moonroof or dashboard, and problems with the 8-speed automatic transmission in 2017-2019 models, leading to noises, delayed shifting, and failure. 
You can watch this video to learn about common problems with Toyota Highlander, including the 8-speed transmission issue: 59sChris DrivesYouTube · Jul 5, 2025
Most common problems

• VVT-i oil line rupture: This is the most frequent and serious issue, where the oil line bursts, causing a massive oil leak that can lead to complete engine failure if the vehicle is driven while the low oil pressure light is on. A revised part has been issued, but it has also been reported to have the same problem. 
• Interior rattles and noises: Many owners report various rattles and squeaks coming from the interior, such as the moonroof, dashboard, or infotainment screen, particularly on bumpy roads or in cold weather. 
• 8-speed automatic transmission: Specific models, particularly the 2017–2019 Highlanders, have been associated with issues such as a whining noise, delayed shifts, hard shifts, and even complete failure. 
• Airbag sensor failure: Some models have a faulty front passenger airbag sensor that can short-circuit, preventing the airbag from deploying correctly. 

Other potential issues

• Air and water leaks: Some model years have reported issues with plugged sunroof drain lines, leading to water leaks inside the vehicle. 
• Check engine light: This can be caused by various issues, such as the hose coming off the air filter housing or a failed oxygen sensor. 
• Brake issues: Some models have reported premature wear of brake pads and rotors, or a vibrating sensation when braking. 

This video discusses problems with the 8-speed transmission in the 2017-2019 Toyota Highlander: 58sThe Car Care NutYouTube · Jul 31, 2021

Is a used Highlander a good buy?

When looking for a used Toyota Highlander, you are considering a vehicle that offers excellent resale value and a strong reputation for longevity. The Highlander is equipped with many features that families appreciate, such as ample seating, user-friendly technology, and a comfortable ride.

What year of Highlander to stay away from?

Years to avoid in the Toyota Highlander include 2003, 2008, 2014, 2015, and 2020 due to common issues like transmission problems, oil leaks, and technology glitches. Other problematic years to consider are 2001-2007 (engine and climate control issues) and 2016-2019 (varying issues including potential oil leaks in some models).
 
This video discusses problems with the Toyota Highlander from 2020 to 2025, including paint issues: 54sCarnivautoYouTube · Feb 11, 2025
Toyota Highlander years to avoid

• 2001–2007: Prone to engine overheating, head gasket failures, and climate control issues like AC compressor and blower motor problems. 
• 2003: A big year for issues, particularly engine oil sludge buildup and premature transmission wear, according to Regan Motors Inc and Clutch. 
• 2008: A redesigned model that experienced oil cooler line leaks, which can cause engine damage if not addressed, and lower-quality interior components. 
• 2014: A recall was issued for the second-row seat assembly that may not lock correctly into the seat track, and there were also reports of issues that might be linked to the transmission, says Clutch and Reddit users. 
• 2015: Experienced growing pains from its redesign, with various reports of growing issues, according to Regan Motors Inc and Clutch. 
• 2020: Experienced early transmission and software problems, say Clutch and Reddit users. 

You can watch this video to learn more about common problems with the 2020-2025 Toyota Highlander: 51sChris DrivesYouTube · Jul 5, 2025

What is the top Toyota Highlander?

The top trim for the Toyota Highlander is the Platinum, which includes features like a Panoramic View Monitor and a large panoramic glass roof. For the larger Toyota Grand Highlander, the top model is the Platinum Hybrid Max with its powerful hybrid powertrain and premium features. 
Toyota Highlander Platinum 

• Key features: Panoramic View Monitor, panoramic glass roof, a 12.3-inch touchscreen display, and a JBL sound system with 11 speakers. 
• Interior: Leather-trimmed seats with heated and ventilated front seats. 
• Drivetrain: Comes standard with all-wheel drive (AWD) on the regular gas model. 

You can watch this video for a review of the Toyota Grand Highlander Platinum Hybrid Max: 59sShooting CarsYouTube · Nov 4, 2025
Toyota Grand Highlander Platinum Hybrid Max

• Key features: Hybrid MAX powertrain (362 net combined horsepower), a 12.3-inch digital gauge cluster, and a power panoramic roof. 
• Interior: Includes heated and ventilated front seats, heated second-row seats, and a power liftgate with hands-free operation. 
• Drivetrain: Comes standard with all-wheel drive. 
• Technology: Features a 360-degree camera, a premium JBL sound system, and wireless Apple CarPlay/Android Auto. 

This video provides a detailed look at the features in the Toyota Grand Highlander Platinum Hybrid Max interior: 56sDiscerning CarsYouTube · Sep 9, 2025