What year is the best year to buy a Toyota Highlander?

For most buyers, a well-maintained late-model used Highlander from the 2014–2019 generation offers the best value. If you want the latest safety tech and warranty coverage, a 2020–present model is appealing, though it will cost more upfront. In short, look for a carefully cared-for 2015–2018 Highlander for best balance, or consider a newer 2020+ if you prioritize modern features.

This article explains which model years tend to offer the best balance of reliability, features and cost, how each generation differs, and practical buying tips to help you choose the right year for your needs.

Model-year guidance: finding the best year to buy

Consider these year ranges for used Highlanders, based on reliability history, feature sets and price. Each range has its own strengths, so your choice should align with budget and priorities.

• 2015–2017: Strong reliability with a good balance of price and features; widely recommended by buyers and reviewers as a solid value in the used market.


• 2018–2019: More modern safety features and updated interior materials while still offering reasonable used prices; good choice if you want newer tech without paying top-dollar.


• 2020–present: The fourth generation, with the latest design, tech and safety features; best if you want a near-new feel and longer remaining warranty, but at a higher initial cost and sharper depreciation.

In practice, any of these ranges can be a smart buy if the specific vehicle has complete maintenance records, a clean recall history and a recent inspection. Prices and availability will vary by region and trim level, and hybrids in particular can command a premium in today’s market.

Generational overview: what to expect by generation

Understanding how the Highlander evolved helps you evaluate what you’re getting for your money. The Highlander has gone through four generations, each with its own strengths and typical trade-offs.

Third generation (2014–2020)

The mid-generation update delivered a more spacious interior, improved ride quality and a broader set of safety and convenience features. This generation is widely regarded as a good balance of comfort, reliability and value on the used market, with many examples delivering long, dependable service when properly maintained.

Fourth generation (2020–present)

The current generation brings a newer design, updated infotainment, and improved safety technology. If you’re looking for the latest features and a longer potential lifespan under warranty, a 2020–2023 model can be very appealing. Expect higher purchase prices and faster depreciation relative to older used models, but you’ll be buying into the newest platform and powertrain options.

Across generations, the Highlander Hybrid has been offered as well, providing a compelling option for buyers prioritizing fuel economy. If fuel savings are a priority, factor in hybrid availability and potential maintenance considerations alongside the gasoline-only variants.

Buying tips: how to secure a solid Highlander deal

Use these steps to minimize risk and maximize value when shopping for a Highlander, regardless of year choice.

1. Check recall history and service records. Verify that all open recalls have been completed and review the maintenance timeline (oil changes, brake work, tires, timing chain/belt if applicable).


2. Perform a thorough inspection and test drive. Listen for unusual noises, check steering response, braking performance, vibration, and door/latch operation. Inspect the suspension and tires for uneven wear.


3. Review vehicle history reports. Look for flood damage, odometer inconsistencies, prior accidents, and service gaps. A clean history plus consistent maintenance is a good sign.


4. Have a qualified mechanic do a pre-purchase inspection. A professional check can uncover wear items (brakes, tires, hoses) and any hidden issues that aren’t obvious on a test drive.


5. Assess the equity of hybrid vs. non-hybrid angles. If you’re considering a hybrid, confirm battery health, charging behavior, and hybrid-system service history specifically.

These steps help you avoid common pitfalls and identify Highlanders that are likely to deliver reliable, long-term ownership. Always factor in local pricing, trim differences, and the presence of certified pre-owned warranties when evaluating bids.

Summary

For most buyers, the sweet spot in the used market is the 2015–2018 Highlander, offering a strong combination of reliability, features and reasonable price. If you want the newest technology and warranty coverage, a 2020–present model is worth considering, though it will cost more upfront. Regardless of year, prioritize a full maintenance history, clean recall status, and a professional pre-purchase inspection to maximize your chances of a trouble-free purchase.

In the end, the best year to buy a Toyota Highlander is the one that balances your budget with well-documented maintenance and a clean history, with optional hybrid powertrains offering additional savings for high-mileage drivers.

Which Highlander to stay away from?

The Toyota Highlander has several troubled years to avoid: 2001–2003, 2005–2007, 2008–2010, 2014–2015, and 2017–2019. Common issues include transmission failures, brake defects, engine problems, electrical faults, and water leaks. Knowing these problem years helps buyers make smarter choices.

Which one is the best Toyota Highlander?

The "best" Toyota Highlander depends on your priorities, as different model years excel in different areas. For reliability, the 2007 and 2008 models are top contenders, while the 2019 model is highly regarded for its well-rounded package and awards for resale value and family-friendliness. For the most features, the Platinum trim is the top-level choice, offering a panoramic glass roof and other upgrades. 
By reliability

• 2007 Highlander: Often cited for its great reliability and safety features, making it a strong choice. 
• 2008 Highlander: Rated as one of the most reliable years and the first to offer a hybrid option. 
• 2018 Highlander: A fine-tuned version of the 2017 model, known for its consistent performance. 

By features and value

• 2019 Highlander: Won awards for Best Resale Value and Best Family Cars, and offered a well-rounded package with a powerful V6 engine. 
• 2017 Highlander: Kicked off a third-generation update with a new engine and updated styling. 
• Platinum Trim: For the newest models, the Platinum trim is the highest level and includes premium features like the Panoramic View Monitor and a panoramic glass roof. 

Considerations for a new or used purchase

• Used: Look for model years with a good reliability record like the 2007, 2008, or 2019 model years. 
• New: The 2021 model year introduced a new generation with a bolder design and more refined interior. 
• Avoid: Some years have known issues; for example, the 2008-2010 models had some problems, and the 2014-2015 and 2017-2019 models are also on some lists to avoid due to issues like transmission failures. 

Best trim for features

• Platinum: If you want the most features, the Platinum is the top trim level, offering premium options like a panoramic glass roof and advanced driver-aid features. 

What year is the most reliable Toyota Highlander?

The most reliable Toyota Highlander years are often cited as the 2008, 2017, 2018, and 2019 models, with the 2008 and 2017 models specifically highlighted for their strong reliability ratings. Some sources also recommend the current fourth generation, starting with the 2020 and 2021 models, though they are still relatively new for long-term data to be fully conclusive. 

• 2008 Toyota Highlander: The first year of the second generation, it has been praised for its reliability and lower maintenance costs. 
• 2017-2019 Toyota Highlander: These years are part of the refreshed third generation and are noted for improvements to the V6 engine and overall design, making them a strong option for reliability and value. 
• 2016 and 2019 Toyota Highlander: Autotrader suggests these are among the best years, along with 2010-2013 models. 
• 2020-2021 Toyota Highlander: The fourth generation, starting in 2020, has shown strong reliability so far, though it is still new and has limited long-term data. 

Important considerations:

• Check for recalls: Always check for recalls on any model year you are considering, especially for models like the 2017-2019 which may have issues with the low-pressure fuel pump or water pump. 
• Hybrid models: If considering a hybrid, ensure that the hybrid battery coolant has been changed regularly according to the manufacturer's recommendations. 
• Specific problems: While overall reliability is high, some models have specific issues, such as the 2002 model year having a slightly below-average repair record. 

Is a used Highlander worth buying?

When looking for a used Toyota Highlander, you are considering a vehicle that offers excellent resale value and a strong reputation for longevity. The Highlander is equipped with many features that families appreciate, such as ample seating, user-friendly technology, and a comfortable ride.