What are the cons of the Honda Pilot?

The Honda Pilot remains a practical, family-friendly SUV, but it has several drawbacks buyers should weigh. The most common cons cited by reviewers and owners include limited third-row space, modest cargo capacity behind the third row, average fuel economy for its class, and some model-year reliability concerns related to the transmission and infotainment. This assessment reflects models available through 2024, including updates from the 2023 refresh that improved tech in higher trims.

Space and practicality

Seating and cargo considerations

Interior usability depends on how you use the second and third rows. While the Pilot offers ample overall cabin room, the third row can feel cramped for adults on longer trips, and cargo behind the third row is comparatively limited versus some rivals.

Here are the main drawbacks related to seating and cargo:

• Third-row seating is tight for adults on extended drives; it's better suited for kids or shorter trips.


• Cargo space behind the third row is modest, limiting packing flexibility when seven or eight passengers are onboard.


• In lower trims, interior materials and controls can feel dated compared with some rivals; higher trims improve feel but may still lag premium brands.

In sum, the Pilot delivers a roomy cabin for families, but the rear seating and cargo layout can limit practicality for peak-loading days.

Performance and efficiency

Power, towing and economy

The Pilot prioritizes ride comfort and safety features over sportier performance. Acceleration is adequate for daily driving, but it can feel sluggish when the vehicle is fully loaded or when towing, and it isn’t among the quickest in its class. Fuel economy is average for a non-hybrid midsize SUV with a V6, not a standout compared with some peers.

Key trade-offs in performance and efficiency include:

• Powertrain is adequate for family duties but not particularly quick or engaging, especially with a full load.


• Handling emphasizes a smooth, comfortable ride over sporty driving dynamics.


• Fuel economy sits in the middle of the segment; some rivals offer better efficiency, particularly with hybrid options.

Overall, the Pilot is comfortable and capable for most everyday use, but it won’t satisfy buyers seeking brisk acceleration or class-leading fuel economy.

Reliability and ownership costs

What owners have reported

Reliability has varied by model year. Some owners have reported issues with the transmission and infotainment system in certain configurations, along with routine maintenance costs typical of a midsize SUV. Major drivetrain repairs can be costly if problems arise, so buyers should review service history and look for any active recalls or campaigns on specific VINs.

When shopping, consider these reliability-oriented points:

• Some mid-generation model years have had transmission-related complaints and service campaigns.


• Infotainment glitches (Bluetooth pairing, touchscreen responsiveness) have been reported by a subset of owners.


• Overall maintenance costs are generally on par with peers, but significant drivetrain repairs can be expensive if problems occur.

In summary, the Pilot’s reliability profile can vary by year; prospective buyers should check the vehicle’s maintenance history, recall status, and any warranty extensions before purchase.

How it compares with rivals

For buyers weighing space, comfort, and value, several rivals offer competing strengths. Here’s where the Pilot generally stacks up against popular alternatives:

• Toyota Highlander — strong reliability and resale value; may have tighter third-row space and different cargo logistics depending on trim.


• Hyundai Palisade and Kia Telluride — widely praised for spacious interiors and strong value; often offer more cargo versatility and newer tech at similar prices.


• Nissan Pathfinder — comfortable ride with modern tech; space and refinements vary by year, and some trims don’t match Palisade/Telluride in interior quality.


• Chevrolet Traverse — typically excels in overall cargo capacity; may lag behind on interior refinement and fuel efficiency compared with the Pilot.

Compared with these rivals, the Pilot remains a solid, safety-forward choice with a practical interior, but its cargo flexibility, efficiency, and the latest tech can lag behind some newer or redesigned competitors.

Summary

The Honda Pilot is a dependable, roomy option for families who value space, safety features, and a comfortable ride. Its primary drawbacks are a third row that isn’t comfortable for adults on long trips, limited cargo space behind the third row, average fuel economy for its class, and model-year variability in reliability—particularly related to the transmission and infotainment systems. Prospective buyers should weigh these cons against rivals that may offer more cargo flexibility, better efficiency, or newer technology, and always check a used Pilot’s maintenance and recall history before purchase.

What are the best and worst years for Honda Pilots?

The best Honda Pilot years are generally considered to be the 2006-2008 and 2017-2021 models, while the worst years to avoid are the 2003, 2005, 2016, and 2017 models due to common issues like transmission problems and high numbers of complaints. For a reliable used option, the 2006-2008 models are solid first-generation choices, and the 2017-2021 models are highly rated for reliability and modern features.
 
Best years

• 2006-2008: Part of the first generation, these models are praised for their solid construction and reliable performance. 
• 2017-2021: These are third-generation models known for significant improvements in technology and safety features, with the 2019 model year frequently cited as a top choice for reliability. 
• 2014: This model is also considered a recommended year by Consumer Reports. 

Worst years

• 2003, 2005, 2016: These years are frequently mentioned as having the most reported problems, particularly with the transmission. 
• 2003: The first model year, it had significant issues with its transmission and interior accessories. 
• 2017: While often considered a good year, some sources list it as a year to avoid due to a higher number of complaints than other models. 
• 2003, 2005, 2009, 2011, 2013, and 2016: Some sources recommend avoiding these years due to recurring issues, such as transmission and electrical problems. 

Is the Honda Pilot a reliable car?

Yes, the Honda Pilot is generally considered a reliable car, known for its longevity and strong performance. It has a reputation for lasting over 200,000 miles with proper maintenance, and it ranks well in terms of owner satisfaction and low major repair issues. However, some model years are considered less reliable than others, and it's important to check the specific model year you are interested in. 
You can watch this video to learn about the best and worst model years for the Honda Pilot: 56sCar ComfyYouTube · Sep 26, 2025
What makes the Pilot a reliable choice

• Longevity: Many Pilots can last for 200,000 miles or more, with some reaching 300,000 miles or more with consistent, proper care. 
• Owner satisfaction: Reviews consistently give the Pilot high marks for reliability and overall satisfaction. 
• Strong engineering: It features a durable frame and suspension, and the V6 engine is both powerful and efficient. 
• Low repair costs: The Pilot has lower-than-average ownership costs, though it may require more frequent, minor repairs compared to some other models. 

Factors to consider

• Model year: Some model years have more reported problems than others. For example, the 2003, 2005, 2009, 2011, 2013, and 2016 model years are cited as years to avoid. 
• Maintenance is key: Regular maintenance, such as oil changes and timely part replacements, is crucial to maximizing the vehicle's lifespan. 
• Driving conditions: The vehicle's durability can be affected by driving conditions. A Pilot driven in moderate climates may last longer than one subjected to harsh conditions. 
• Used vehicle history: When buying a used Pilot, research the specific model year and check its maintenance history. 

What is the most common problem with the Honda Pilot?

The most common problem with the Honda Pilot is transmission failure, often caused by a faulty radiator that allows coolant to leak into the transmission fluid, leading to expensive damage. Other widespread issues include problems with the Vehicle Stability Assist (VSA) system, which can cause unintended braking, and various electrical and infotainment system malfunctions.
 
This video discusses common problems in the second generation Honda Pilot, including airbag recalls and engine issues: 59sMJ100kYouTube · Sep 30, 2025
Transmission and cooling system

• Coolant-transmission fluid mixing: A radiator design flaw can cause coolant to leak into the transmission fluid, leading to transmission failure. 
• Symptoms: Drivers report shuddering, jerking, and sudden loss of power, with failures often occurring between 120,000 and 150,000 miles. 
• Solutions: Repairs are costly and can involve a full transmission replacement. 

Electrical and computer systems 

• Vehicle Stability Assist (VSA) system: Some models experience the VSA system applying the brakes without driver input, which can be dangerous. This is often traced to a faulty yaw sensor. 
• Infotainment system: Issues like blank screens, malfunctioning wireless chargers, and inoperable backup cameras have been reported, particularly in newer models. 
• Auto start/stop system: The engine's auto start/stop system has been reported to malfunction, sometimes failing to restart the engine. 

This video highlights trending issues in the 2023-2025 Honda Pilot, including broken battery sensor wires: 1mBCauto_YouTube · Jan 30, 2025
Engine and emissions

• Engine issues: Some older models have had issues with engine sludge due to piston ring deterioration. 
• Emissions system: Warning lights may indicate a problem with the fuel injectors or catalytic converter. 
• Oil consumption: Some models have reported excessive oil consumption. 

You can watch this video to learn what the owner wishes they knew before buying the Honda Pilot, including infotainment and engine issues: 58sAdventure Gear TVYouTube · Apr 9, 2022
Other problems

• Brake issues: Warped front brake rotors causing vibration and problems with the anti-lock braking system have been reported. 
• Water intrusion: Some models have reported water leaks, particularly in the rear, which can cause electrical problems. 
• Airbag recalls: Certain model years, especially the second generation (2009-2015), have been affected by airbag recalls. 

What are the downsides of the Honda Pilot?

The main downsides of the Honda Pilot include electrical system problems like sensor glitches and infotainment issues, and mechanical concerns such as potential transmission issues and brake vibration. Other drawbacks include a lack of hybrid options, poor fuel efficiency compared to some rivals, and a cramped third-row seat for adults. 
Electrical and technology

• Infotainment and sensor glitches: Owners have reported problems with the infotainment screen freezing, and sensors (especially those for collision avoidance) can malfunction, leading to random braking. 
• Outdated technology: The infotainment system can feel dated, and driver-assistance features like adaptive cruise control might not be as smooth or available on all trims until later model years. 
• Electrical issues: Other reported problems include the auto start-stop system failing and general battery drain issues. 

Mechanical and performance

• Transmission concerns: Some models, particularly older ones, have experienced transmission problems like slipping, rough shifting, and occasional hard downshifts. 
• Brake vibration: Brake vibration, often caused by warped rotors, is a frequently reported issue. 
• Fuel efficiency: The Pilot's fuel efficiency is not class-leading, and there are no hybrid or plug-in hybrid options available. 
• Third-row space: While spacious overall, the third row is often described as being cramped for adults. 

Other potential issues

• Oil consumption: Some models may experience excessive oil consumption, which can lead to higher maintenance costs.
• Peeling paint: Peeling paint has been cited as a cosmetic issue that could become a more significant problem in certain climates.
• Recurring fault codes: False or recurring fault codes can be a nuisance and may mask a genuine issue.