Home FAQ

What is the most common problem with Honda Pilots?

The most common problem with Honda Pilots is transmission failure, particularly in older model years. This issue can be a significant and costly repair for Pilot owners, often requiring a complete transmission replacement.

Transmission Troubles in Honda Pilots

Honda Pilots, known for their reliability and versatility, have faced a recurring issue with their transmissions. The problem is most prevalent in Pilot models from the early to mid-2000s, with many owners reporting premature transmission failure, often before the vehicle reaches 100,000 miles.

The transmission in the Honda Pilot is a critical component, responsible for transferring power from the engine to the wheels. When this component fails, it can lead to a range of problems, including:

Difficulty shifting gears

Sudden loss of power

Jerking or shuddering during acceleration

Inability to maintain speed on hills or inclines

In severe cases, the transmission may completely fail, leaving the vehicle inoperable and requiring a costly replacement.

Causes and Preventive Measures

The transmission issues in Honda Pilots are believed to be caused by a combination of factors, including design flaws, heat buildup, and the demanding nature of the Pilot's powertrain. Owners have reported that the transmission fluid in their Pilots can break down prematurely, leading to increased wear and tear on the internal components.

To help prevent or mitigate transmission problems, Honda Pilot owners are advised to:

Regularly change the transmission fluid, following the manufacturer's recommended schedule

Avoid towing heavy loads or driving the vehicle in extreme conditions, such as steep hills or hot weather, which can put additional strain on the transmission

Consider upgrading to a more robust aftermarket transmission if the factory unit is prone to failure

By being proactive and addressing any potential transmission issues early on, Honda Pilot owners can help extend the life of this critical component and avoid the costly and inconvenient experience of a complete transmission replacement.

What year did Honda Pilot have transmission problems?

The main years for Honda Pilot transmission problems are 2003, 2005, and 2016, with the 2003 model being particularly prone to transmission failure. While the 2003 and 2005 years are known for significant issues, the 2016 model also has many owner complaints related to its new transmission, as well as engine and electrical problems. Other models like 2017-2020 have been investigated for issues with the 9-speed transmission and the stop-start system.
This video demonstrates a common Honda Pilot transmission issue and explains what to do: 58sAleksandr UsovichYouTube · Aug 27, 2021
Specific model years with notable transmission issues

2003: This year is infamous for transmission failures, which can be very expensive to fix or replace.
2005: Also experienced transmission problems, with owners reporting issues.
2016: This model year saw a high number of complaints, including a new transmission, engine problems, and electrical system issues.
2017-2020: The 6-speed transmission in some of these models, and the 9-speed in others, can have issues, and the stop-start system has also been a source of complaints.

What to keep in mind when buying an older Honda Pilot

Check maintenance records: Properly maintained transmissions are less likely to have problems.
Consider the model year: 2003, 2005, and 2016 are known problematic years. Newer models (2017-2020) may have issues with the stop-start system.
Get a pre-purchase inspection: Have a mechanic thoroughly inspect the vehicle, paying close attention to the transmission, before buying.
Be aware of recall status: Check if any recalls have been performed, especially for models like 2016, which had several recalls.

Which years of Honda Pilot to avoid?

Years of the Honda Pilot to avoid include 2003, 2004, 2005, 2011, 2016, and 2017 due to recurring issues like transmission problems, engine issues, and electrical malfunctions. The 2003 model is the first year and had numerous complaints, while the 2005 model had persistent transmission fluid leaks and defective torque converters. The 2016 model, which was a redesign year, suffered from transmission, engine, and electrical problems, as did the 2017 model, according to CarBuzz and AGT Europe Automotive Import SA.
Specific years to avoid and their issues:

2003: First model year with numerous complaints and recalls, particularly a Takata airbag defect.
2004: Has a high number of complaints, according to CarBuzz.
2005: Suffered from persistent transmission problems, including fluid leaks and torque converter issues.
2011: Reported to have transmission and other issues, according to AGT Europe Automotive Import SA.
2016: A redesign year with widespread issues including transmission, engine, and electrical problems.
2017: Had a high number of complaints related to engine and transmission issues, according to CarBuzz.
2018: Had multiple recalls for issues like the fuel injection system and other electronic problems.
2020: Has recall issues with the backup camera and display screen freezing, as well as a rough ride feel.
2022: Has reported issues with the transmission, including hesitation and rough shifting.

What is the most reliable year of the Honda Pilot?

The most reliable Honda Pilot years are often considered to be the 2008, 2015, and 2018 model years, as they represent the end of their respective generations and have fewer reported complaints. Other models with strong reliability reputations include the 2014, 2017-2021, and 2022 years, though some of the latter years had a few recalls. The 2016 model is frequently cited as a year to avoid.

This video explains the best and worst years for Honda Pilot based on reliability: 56sCar ComfyYouTube · Sep 26, 2025
Recommended years

2008: The last year of the first generation, known for its reliability.
2014 and 2015: The final years of the second generation, often cited as particularly dependable and well-refined.
2017-2021: Generally have fewer complaints than other years in the third generation, though some recalls occurred.
2018: Specifically noted for being a reliable year, particularly the 6-speed automatic transmission versions.
2022: Considered one of the most reliable models in its generation, although it did have a few recalls.

Years to approach with caution

2016: Often cited as a less reliable model year to avoid.
2003 and 2005: Have been identified as having more problems than other models in their generation.

Does the Honda Pilot have problems?

Engine problems are also commonly reported among Pilot owners. Drivers frequently describe situations involving engine stalling, difficulty starting, erratic idle speeds, misfires, overheating, and excessive oil consumption.

Kevin Bennett

Company Owner

Kevin Bennet is the founder and owner of Kevin's Autos, a leading automotive service provider in Australia. With a deep commitment to customer satisfaction and years of industry expertise, Kevin uses his blog to answer the most common questions posed by his customers. From maintenance tips to troubleshooting advice, Kevin's articles are designed to empower drivers with the knowledge they need to keep their vehicles running smoothly and safely.