Is Lexus more reliable than German cars?
In brief, Lexus generally ranks higher for reliability than many German luxury brands, though results vary by model and year.
Reliability comparisons between Lexus and German automakers such as BMW, Mercedes-Benz, and Audi depend on how you measure it. This article reviews the latest data from independent rankings and owner surveys, and explains what drives the differences and how shoppers should evaluate individual models.
What the data says about reliability
Reliability scores come from independent surveys and owner reports. Here are the prominent sources used to compare Lexus and German luxury brands:
- Consumer Reports reliability ratings for brands and individual models, where Lexus often ranks near the top and German brands show more variability by model.
- J.D. Power Vehicle Dependability Study, which typically places Lexus models high for dependability, with German luxury options performing well in some segments and less consistently in others.
- Long-term ownership and recall data from manufacturers and industry trackers, highlighting generally lower maintenance frequency for Lexus compared with some German rivals, though regional differences and model dependence exist.
Across these sources, the trend is that Lexus tends to outperform typical German luxury brands for reliability, but there are notable exceptions and variations by model, generation, and year.
Model-by-model nuance
Not all Lexus models outrun their German counterparts in reliability. Some German luxury models—especially certain BMW, Mercedes, or Audi lines—offer strong reliability in specific generations and benefit from newer platforms that improved electronics and build quality. Buyers should research the exact model-year reliability history and consider maintenance costs when comparing used options.
Costs of ownership and maintenance considerations
Beyond reliability, total ownership costs influence true value. Here are the main cost factors for Lexus versus German luxury cars:
- Purchase price and depreciation: Lexus vehicles often depreciate more slowly than some German luxury rivals, depending on the model and market.
- Maintenance and repair costs: Parts and service for German marques can be more expensive, especially for luxury components and specialized electronics.
- Warranty coverage and servicing: Brand-backed warranties, maintenance plans, and dealership networks affect out-of-pocket costs.
- Fuel economy and drivetrain choices: Hybrid Lexus models may offer favorable mpg and lower running costs in some segments; many German rivals offer efficient engines and plug-in options as well.
- Insurance costs: Insurance premiums vary with model, safety ratings, and repair costs, often making European luxury brands more expensive to insure.
In practice, Lexus generally delivers lower ongoing maintenance costs and steadier depreciation in many markets, while German luxury cars can hold value well in certain high-demand segments but may require more frequent maintenance on older models.
Summary
Overall, Lexus tends to be more reliable on average than many German luxury brands, according to major reliability studies and owner surveys. The gap is not uniform: specific models, years, and generations can buck the trend, and German brands offer strong reliability in certain segments and exceptional performance. For buyers, the best approach is to examine model-specific reliability histories, maintenance costs, and warranty coverage, and to weigh reliability against performance and technology preferences.
Where does Lexus rank in reliability?
Compact Contenders: Lexus ES, Lexus RX, Lexus NX, and Lexus IS Reliability Rankings
| Model | Category | 2024 Reliability Ranking |
|---|---|---|
| Lexus ES | Midsize Premium Car | 1st |
| Lexus RX | Midsize Premium SUV | 2nd |
| Lexus NX | Compact Premium SUV | 3rd |
| Lexus IS | Compact Premium Car | 4th |
Are Lexus more reliable than German cars?
If you're on the fence about Lexus vs Acura, they are both way more reliable than our German competition. You cant go wrong either way.
Which one is more reliable, Lexus or BMW?
Lexus stands at the top of the competition in terms of dependability with a score of 135 PP100. This is a full 55 problems per 100 vehicles lower than the industry average of 190 PP 100 Compared to the BMW score of 190 PP100, exactly average. Lexus is the clear winner in terms of dependability.
What car is ranked #1 in reliability?
Subaru Tops Reliability
Subaru has ascended to the top of our brand rankings, supplanting Lexus and Toyota, which have traded the two top spots for many years.
